A Doctor Explains When to See a Doctor for Common Illnesses

Recurring Problems/Confusions Identified:

  1. When is it "worth it" to see a doctor for common illnesses? (Core frustration: cost/time vs. benefit)
  2. Why can't doctors "cure" a cold/flu? (Misunderstanding of viral vs. bacterial, role of antibiotics)
  3. How long should an illness last before seeking medical attention? (Lack of clear guidelines)
  4. What are the specific symptoms that DO warrant a doctor visit for an otherwise "normal" illness? ("Red flags")
  5. How do I know if it's bacterial (needing antibiotics) vs. viral? (A key differentiator for treatment)
  6. Frustration with the US healthcare system's cost and accessibility for minor issues. (Relatable pain point)
  7. Feeling like one needs to be their "own advocate" with doctors. (Desire for empowerment)

Content Idea Proposals:

Idea 1: "The 'Should I See a Doctor?' Checklist for Common Illnesses (US Edition)"

  • Content Concept: An authoritative yet empathetic piece (article, infographic, or short video featuring a doctor) that validates the frustration of expensive doctor visits for minor things. It would provide clear, evidence-based guidelines:
    • Typical duration for common viral illnesses (cold, flu).
    • "Red Flag" symptoms that absolutely warrant a visit (e.g., fever over X°F for Y days, shortness of breath, severe localized pain, inability to keep fluids down, specific rash types, sudden worsening after initial improvement).
    • Symptoms more indicative of bacterial infection (e.g., strep-like sore throat, potential pneumonia symptoms after a flu).
    • When self-care (rest, fluids, OTC meds) is appropriate.
    • A brief mention of when urgent care might be a better/cheaper option than a PCP or ER for non-emergency but concerning symptoms.
  • Why it could go viral: Directly addresses the core frustration, offers actionable advice, empowers users, and helps save money/time. The "US Edition" makes it specific and relatable.
  • Target Audience: General adult population in the US, especially those cost-conscious about healthcare, parents of young children, or anyone who frequently questions the necessity of doctor visits for acute illnesses.

Idea 2: "ELI5: Viral vs. Bacterial Infections – Why Your Doctor Isn't Giving You Antibiotics for That Cold"

  • Content Concept: A simple, easy-to-understand explainer (article with clear diagrams, animated short) that clarifies:
    • What viruses and bacteria are.
    • How they cause illness differently.
    • Why antibiotics only work on bacteria.
    • The dangers of antibiotic overuse (superbugs).
    • Common symptoms that help differentiate (though acknowledging a doctor's diagnosis is sometimes needed).
    • What doctors can do for viral infections (symptom management, ruling out complications).
  • Why it could go viral: Addresses a very common misunderstanding. "ELI5" (Explain Like I'm 5) format is popular for complex topics. Reduces patient-doctor friction over antibiotic requests.
  • Target Audience: General public, particularly those who may not understand the limitations of antibiotics or feel frustrated when not prescribed them. Also useful for parents.

Idea 3: "My Doctor Said 'It's Just a Virus.' Now What? (A Patient's Guide to Self-Care & When to Follow Up)"

  • Content Concept: This piece acknowledges the (sometimes dismissive-sounding) diagnosis of a viral illness and empowers the patient.
    • Validates that even "just a virus" can make you feel awful.
    • Provides a comprehensive guide to effective OTC treatments and home remedies (what works, what's a myth).
    • Clearly outlines "return precautions": symptoms that indicate the viral illness might be complicated, not resolving as expected, or something else is going on (e.g., secondary bacterial infection, symptoms lasting beyond 7-10 days without improvement, new or worsening symptoms).
    • Briefly touches on how to phrase concerns if a follow-up is needed.
  • Why it could go viral: Highly relatable scenario. Empowers patients with actionable self-care advice and clear guidance on when "just a virus" isn't just a virus anymore. Addresses the feeling of being dismissed.
  • Target Audience: Anyone who has ever been told they "just have a virus," adults managing their own or family illnesses, those seeking to be more proactive in their healthcare.

Idea 4: "Is It Allergies, a Cold, the Flu, or COVID-19? A Symptom Decoder"

  • Content Concept: A comparative chart or interactive quiz that helps users differentiate between common respiratory illnesses based on typical symptom onset, presence/absence of fever, type of cough, body aches, etc.
    • Emphasize that it's not a diagnostic tool but can help guide self-care decisions and whether/when to seek testing or medical advice.
    • Include "when to test for COVID/Flu" guidelines.
  • Why it could go viral: Perennial question, especially seasonally and since COVID. Highly practical and shareable.
  • Target Audience: General public, especially during cold/flu/allergy seasons.

Origin Reddit Post

r/nostupidquestions

Does anyone else feel like going to the doctor doesn't help with normal illnesses?

Posted by u/DarkFlowerPewPew06/11/2025
Probably unreasonable but I get so annoyed when family members tell me to go to the doctor when I tell them I'm sick and it's been like two days. I live in the US for reference. Based on my

Top Comments

u/Corona688
most normal illnesses can't be cured, only treated, and unless you're fucking dying, the treatment is the same thing you'd be buying at the store.
u/untetheredgrief
Wow, where do you live? My doctor will see sick visits same-day or next-day. And if they couldn't, there is always urgent care.
u/fwibs
The only reason I go to the doctor for something routine is if I need a work excuse because yeah, you're just gonna be told what you already know: Rest, fluids, Tylenol/ibuprofen ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ U
u/DarkFlowerPewPew
Oh, it's likely not my doctor but someone else at the practice as a whole.
u/Deep_Alps7150
I've had autoimmune/thyroid issues for years, gave up on any doctor helping locally since they are all mid and just cycle through different meds that don't help.
u/Tricky_Jaguar5781
It is my professional opinion (having paid $$$$ for exams), that doctors can ensure they save your life when you are in fact dying, but are ineffective at almost everything else. I have to re
u/zeugma888
I agree - for lots of minor illnesses - cold, upset stomach etc you are better off staying at home, resting and waiting it out. Doctors are good when you need a diagnosis, or a prescription
u/WFOMO
*That being said, most mild illnesses are viral so antibiotics aren't necessary.* Needed repeating....
u/Gladyskravitz99
My doctors can't figure anything out. It's constant guessing and all wrong guesses. My mom died because they didn't know anything. My dad died because the VA took too long to diagnose his (ap
u/mistermojorizin
it gets even worse when it's not normal illnesses. they can't ever figure out what it is. it's not like House.
u/jacrae0201
Can't be a poor example if you're not alone. I've been waiting for a referral for 3 months.
u/gulpamatic
Doctor here. You are correct that most minor illnesses can be treated with time, rest, and common sense. When a doctor gets a cold or the flu, they don't take antibiotics or vitamin c or zinc
u/Lost_Needleworker285
I mean there's nothing they can do about normal illnesses, so unless you've been Ill for a extended period of time with no sign of getting better, all you can do is rest and take over the cou
u/tacmed85
>antibiotics (usually) can't be bought over the counter That's because over use of antibiotics causes super bugs which are bad for everyone. There's way too many people who would run out
u/Trixie3225
You definitely have to be your own advocate. I used to think people were exaggerating when they said that. Nope, not these days.
u/sexrockandroll
Urgent cares. Which isn't a doctor, usually, but some medical professional.
u/TheMonkeyDidntDoIt
This is dependent on a few factors. In the US antibiotics (usually) can't be bought over the counter, so if you have a bacterial infection that requires treatment you would need a prescriptio
u/Esmereldathebrave
Where are you in the US that you can get in to see a doctor in a day or two? If I want to see my doc, even if its something serious, minimum 2 month wait for first available appointment. Ev
u/nkdeck07
Uh yeah cause there's nothing they CAN do for you. Why are you seeing a doctor when you've been sick for 2 days? Go home and get some rest, fluids and over the counter meds. Do you think they
u/sexrockandroll
I've had bad experiences with medical staff, so I do ask myself "why bother to go, what can they do" and will only go if I suspect a specific medicine could help - e.g. I suspect strep throat
u/Gullible_Bigfoot
Well they can test you to see if you have the flu, strep or Covid for instance. Also x-ray your lungs to see if you have pneumonia, and prescribe antibiotics you can’t get over the counter an
u/miss-swait
The only time I would ever go see a doctor for regular illness is if I had it for more than a week and it wasn’t clearing on its own, because at that point it’s probably bacterial and I need
u/LadyGreyIcedTea
There are same day appointments set aside for sick visits. Usually a nurse screens your symptoms and then schedules an appointment if needed.
u/SpambidextrousUser
99% of the time it doesn’t help. Only helps to lighten your wallet and rob you of time.
u/Momof3CMM
They can do a flu test. Mine always prescribes better drugs than you can get over the counter. $300 is ridiculous. Don’t you have insurance?

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started