Automated Final Paycheck Compliance SaaS for Legally Complex Departures
Reddit Post Analysis:
- ID: 1l2s6ii
- Title: "Law firm nonsense — why did I even get a paycheck?"
- Content Summary: An attorney gave two weeks' notice, was told that day would be their last, and then received a final paycheck that seemed inexplicably small or incorrect, leading to confusion about deductions and compliance.
- Comment Summary:
- FLSA (Fair Labor Standards Act): Discussions around minimum wage requirements, overtime exemptions, and the "professional exemption" for attorneys. There's confusion even among commenters about how FLSA applies, especially regarding minimum wage for exempt professionals.
- State Laws: Several comments highlight that state laws can be more stringent than FLSA or have different provisions (e.g., regarding deductions or exemptions).
- Deductions: The core issue for the original poster. Comments discuss the legality of deductions that might take an employee below minimum wage.
- Notice Periods: Whether employers must pay for a notice period if they ask the employee to leave early.
- Employment Contracts: The importance of reviewing employment contracts for terms related to final pay and deductions.
- Clarity and Risk: Significant confusion is evident, implying a high risk for employers of making mistakes in final paycheck calculations, potentially leading to legal issues.
Niche Market Opportunity Analysis:
- Identified Niche: Compliance and calculation for final paychecks, especially for professional service firms (like law firms) or SMBs dealing with salaried/exempt employees and complex state/federal regulations.
- Pain Points Addressed:
- Confusion over FLSA and state-specific labor laws regarding final pay.
- Risk of illegal deductions or miscalculations leading to wage claims.
- Administrative burden of manually calculating final pay while ensuring compliance.
- Lack of clarity for both employers and departing employees.
- Specific complexities for exempt "professional" employees.
SaaS Opportunity:
- Opportunity: A SaaS tool designed to accurately calculate final paychecks for departing employees, ensuring compliance with federal (FLSA) and state-specific labor laws, while considering employment contract terms, exempt/non-exempt status, and various deduction scenarios.
- Product Form:
- Web-based Final Paycheck Compliance Calculator & Documentation Platform.
- Key Features:
- Input for employee details (salary, exempt/non-exempt status, state of employment, hire/termination date, reason for termination).
- Database of up-to-date federal and state-specific labor laws regarding final pay (e.g., timing of payment, permissible deductions, payment for accrued vacation, notice period obligations).
- Module for inputting terms from employment contracts relevant to separation.
- Calculation engine that considers all inputs to determine legally compliant final pay.
- Flags potential compliance issues (e.g., "Proposed deduction X will take employee below state minimum wage").
- Generation of a detailed final pay statement for the employee.
- Generation of compliance documentation/audit trail for the employer.
- Option to handle different scenarios: resignation with notice worked, resignation with early dismissal by employer, termination for cause, layoff.
- Integration with existing payroll systems (optional advanced feature).
- Expected Revenue:
- Model: Monthly or annual subscription.
- Tiers:
- Small Business/Single Firm: $75 - $250/month (depending on the number of employees or final paychecks processed per month/year).
- HR Consultancies/PEO Add-on: Could be licensed to HR consultants or PEOs who manage this for multiple clients.
- Value Proposition:
- Risk Mitigation: Avoids costly legal fees, penalties, and settlements from incorrect final pay. This is the primary value driver.
- Time Savings: Reduces administrative time spent by HR or partners researching laws and performing manual calculations.
- Accuracy & Compliance: Ensures adherence to complex and varying regulations.
- Peace of Mind: For employers, knowing they are handling separations correctly.
Origin Reddit Post
r/lawyertalk
Law firm nonsense — why did I even get a paycheck?
Posted by u/BookkeeperRoutine237•06/04/2025
I gave my two weeks’ notice at my old firm, and instead of letting me work through it, the partner told me that day would be my last. Fine — I figured I’d at least get a clean wrap-up.
I had
Top Comments
u/Aggravating_Wolf_217
I’m at a government agency and my contract requires at minimum 6 weeks notice prior to resigning with very few exceptions. We had someone try to give their notice (3 weeks) and my work reject
u/morgaine125
It’s most likely a state law issue that prohibits them from deducting so much from your paycheck that they would be net paying you less than minimum wage for the pay period.
u/dustinsc
Very few people are exempt from the FLSA’s minimum wage requirement. The exemption people refer to with respect to “FLSA exempt employees” is overtime.
u/Vegetable-Money4355
Doesn’t 13(a)(1) exempt salaried “professionals” (which includes attorneys) from both over time and minimum wage requirements of FLSA?
u/NegativeStructure
> People that run law firms are generally idiots.
i mean... yeah, they're lawyers lol.
u/dapperpappi
What state
u/[deleted]
[deleted]
u/RunningObjection
That shows you aren’t making a mistake by leaving. Not a bit of class.
u/Interesting_Pay3483
Read your contract!
u/lawtalkingirl
If you didn’t sign something in advance allowing the reduction, they can’t change you pay retroactively.
u/joeschmoe86
A certain mid-sized firm in Minneapolis?
u/[deleted]
[deleted]
u/Tardisgoesfast
Send them a letter figuring your salary at the rate you were getting, then deduct the money you think you owe them.
u/BookkeeperRoutine237
I read the contract, but I am now realizing from the comments that they probably didn't put the deduction in the paystub because I wouldn't get paid at all (below minimum wage). So they just
u/Triumph-TBird
FLSA controls. This is normal.
u/NewLawGuy24
READ this all of you. 2 weeks’ notice means nothing
u/NewLawGuy24
READ this all of you. 2 weeks’ notice means mothing
u/lawtalkingirl
If you didn’t sign something in advance allowing the reduction, they can’t change you pay retroactively.
u/Dee__Dubs
The "white collar" exemptions apply to minimum wage and overtime. It's just that there is a salary threshold requirement that is high enough where the employee ends up making much higher than
u/TwoMatchBan
Wow, that is really sketchy behavior by the firm. You likely have contract and wage claims. Depending on your state, you may be entitled to double or treble damages plus attorney’s fees, so t
u/IS606
If they don't make this right, I would consider filing a complaint with the bar for this type of conduct. I don't have that much familiarity with labor regulations so I wouldn't know if what
u/BookkeeperRoutine237
I read the contract, but I am now realizing from the comments that they probably didn't put the deduction in the paystub because I wouldn't get paid at all (below minimum wage). So they just
u/Tardisgoesfast
Send them a letter figuring your salary at the rate you were getting, then deduct the money you think you owe them.
u/B-Rite-Back
The nice thing is, this will make sure you never get nostalgic or wonder if you made the right decision.
u/Afraid-Put8165
I gave two weeks at a large ID firm. They are like in every city. I expected them to show me door. I was hoping they would as I wanted to fly home and see my parents and go see my sister an
u/Vegetable-Money4355
Aren’t attorneys (and most other higher salaried employees) exempt from FLSA? I’ve had this issue come up in an employment case of mine (only one I ever did), and because the employee was an
u/Munchlaxatives
I gave 30 days (!) notice in a similar situation and my boss acted surprised I wasn’t motivated to find work and bill like normal
u/simplytryingtolive00
damn wtf
u/Vegetable-Money4355
Doesn’t 13(a)(1) exempt salaried “professionals” (which includes attorneys) from both over time and minimum wage requirements of FLSA?
u/RunningObjection
That shows you aren’t making a mistake by leaving. Not a bit of class.
u/dustinsc
The FLSA requires them to pay you minimum wage for time worked. They can’t make deductions from your paycheck that would drop you below minimum wage except for certain enumerated things.
u/Montanabioguy
So, some companies have policies which require departing employees to give two weeks notice. Violate that policy and you can get put on a no-rehire list within that organization.
The most c
u/PMJamesPM
A smart, principled organization is transparent, professional, well documented and will use the ‘why’ of the employee’s departure as a learning tool as the reasons why people leave often illu
u/Altruistic_Field2134
Ya know for a class of professionals that literally write the laws for all these types of laws, I'm learning we get jack shit when it comes to any type of employee protection. Like when I fo
u/Little_Bishop1
Lmao that’s the funniest thing I’ve read.
u/morgaine125
It’s most likely a state law issue that prohibits them from deducting so much from your paycheck that they would be net paying you less than minimum wage for the pay period.
u/Interesting_Pay3483
Read your contract!
u/Vegetable-Money4355
Aren’t attorneys (and most other higher salaried employees) exempt from FLSA? I’ve had this issue come up in an employment case of mine (only one I ever did), and because the employee was an
u/dustinsc
Oh wow, I completely forgot about the FLSA professional exemption because my state didn’t have that exemption for the state minimum wage. Professionals were exempt from overtime requirements
u/dustinsc
Oh wow, I completely forgot about the FLSA professional exemption because my state didn’t have that exemption for the state minimum wage. Professionals were exempt from overtime requirements
u/dustinsc
The FLSA requires them to pay you minimum wage for time worked. They can’t make deductions from your paycheck that would drop you below minimum wage except for certain enumerated things.
u/Afraid-Put8165
I gave two weeks at a large ID firm. They are like in every city. I expected them to show me door. I was hoping they would as I wanted to fly home and see my parents and go see my sister an
u/Munchlaxatives
I gave 30 days (!) notice in a similar situation and my boss acted surprised I wasn’t motivated to find work and bill like normal
u/dustinsc
Very few people are exempt from the FLSA’s minimum wage requirement. The exemption people refer to with respect to “FLSA exempt employees” is overtime.
u/Little_Bishop1
Lmao that’s the funniest thing I’ve read.
u/Triumph-TBird
FLSA controls. This is normal.