Brand Equity Lessons: Consumers Value Prestige and Legacy Over Generic Rebranding.

Published on 06/24/2025Trend Spotting / Early Adopter Signals

The heated and largely critical discussion around the 'HBO Max' to 'Max' name change, and the community's hope for a reversal, highlights a crucial lesson in brand management: the immense, often overlooked value of established brand equity and consumer goodwill. It's clear that 'HBO' carries significant prestige, representing decades of high-quality content. The shift to 'Max' was widely seen as diluting this hard-won identity, an attempt to turn a premium brand into a generic entertainment offering, leading to mockery and consumer alienation.

Commercial and Marketing Opportunities:

  1. Brand Strategy Consultants & Agencies: This is a prime example for consultants to showcase the risks of rebranding that ignore consumer perception and legacy value.

    • Opportunity: Offer "Brand Heritage Audits" or "Consumer Sentiment Analysis" services to companies considering rebranding, especially those with strong legacy brands.
    • Marketing Angle: Develop content like white papers, webinars, and articles titled "The 'Max' Mistake: Why Ignoring Brand Equity is a Multi-Million Dollar Blunder" or "Preserving Prestige: Navigating Rebrands Without Alienating Your Core Audience."
  2. B2B Content Marketers & Thought Leadership: Create content targeting CMOs, Brand Managers, and C-suite executives.

    • Opportunity: Produce in-depth analyses, case studies, and opinion pieces on the tangible costs of brand dilution (subscriber loss, negative PR, internal morale) versus the long-term benefits of brand loyalty.
    • Marketing Angle: Position this as a cautionary tale. Emphasize that "simplification" or "broadening appeal" should not come at the cost of a brand's core identity and unique selling proposition. Focus on the theme: "Don't fix what isn't broken, especially if your customers love it."
  3. Market Research Firms: There's an opportunity to offer specialized research services.

    • Opportunity: Conduct studies on how consumers perceive brand changes, especially the impact of merging high-prestige brands with broader, more generic ones. Offer services that go beyond surface-level focus groups to truly understand deep-seated brand attachments.
    • Marketing Angle: "Understanding Your Brand's 'HBO': Uncovering the Intangible Assets Your Consumers Value Most."
  4. Internal Communications & Change Management Experts:

    • Opportunity: Companies undergoing significant brand changes often neglect internal buy-in. This case highlights how external ridicule can impact employee morale and belief in the company's direction. Experts can offer services to help leadership communicate the "why" behind such changes more effectively, or manage the fallout when such changes are poorly received.
    • Marketing Angle: "Leading Through Brand Turmoil: Aligning Internal Teams When External Sentiment Shifts."

The core lesson to market is the enduring power of consumer attachment to trusted, high-prestige brands. Any move perceived as devaluing or genericizing such a brand will likely meet fierce resistance, highlighting that brand identity is a deeply emotional and valuable asset that should be handled with extreme care and respect for consumer sentiment.

Origin Reddit Post

r/outoftheloop

What's the deal with Max switching its name back to HBO Max?

Posted by u/Steelizard06/24/2025
Why are they switching it back now, what was wrong with "Max"? https://www.npr.org/2025/05/15/nx-s1-5399115/max-rebrand-hbo

Top Comments

u/Lou_Garoup
HBO and Warner Bros paid consultants a shitload of money that initially recommended changing the name to HBOMax after a merger and then a few years later they paid consultants a shitload of m
u/FridayMcNight
Still baffling that they just threw away one of the most valued brands in home entertainment. It’s a move so fucking dumb that B-school students will be forced to read case studies on it 5
u/kamahaoma
Funnily enough I heard almost the opposite explanation. HBO is a brand associated with adult fare - to some people HBO means cursing and boobs. They were adding tons of family-friendly conten
u/tinteoj
> has been known for top tier television series since 1999 when the Sopranos aired. The Sopranos rightfully get a lot of the credit, but *Oz* opened the door for *The Sopranos* and gets l
u/percypersimmon
Also they have paid a consulting firm several hundred million dollars to tell them to change the name and then to change it back again.
u/raditaz
/r/lowstakesconspiracies
u/RockShrimp
And joined.
u/bradyso
It's shocking that these idiots get paid millions.
u/sgtmattie
I buy my sheets from a company called “bed” and it drives me bonkers how annoying it is to Google when I need new sheets because I have to specify “bed sheets Vancouver” to actually find it.
u/bobwinters
Sounds similar to Star Trek Enterprise. It was initially called Enterprise. They then clawed back the name Star Trek.
u/fptackle
Bachelor Chow, now with flavor!
u/john_the_doe
A merge like that must’ve had a lot of leadership people protecting their own interests. Naming it HBO Max now or before definitely dilutes the HBO brand name. But unless it’s going to be i
u/Knute5
Answer: Same reason Pizza Hut execs wanted to call it The Hut and fans got angry. Or when Coke tried to put out New Coke and people got angry. Execs change things because they want to make an
u/Infamous_Alpaca
Lucky you. When I was talking with support before, they said that my deal (50% off as long as I don't unsubscribe) was with the previous company, HBO Max, and was not carried over to the new
u/QuilledRaptors2001
> Same reason Pizza Hut execs wanted to call it The Hut I feel these decisions also share the combining factor of "no one knows what you are selling with these generic names lmao" I've h
u/The_bruce42
It was such a dumb decision to move away from it in the first place.
u/Hungry-Western9191
What to do when you have infinite money and can't spend it fast enough. Presumably they west wanted to shrink the market a bit so that when they went through with their current enshittificati
u/Uphoria
There is no deeper reason op. Everyone mocked them for going to just Max because of this reason, and now they're clawing it back. 
u/MysteryRadish
Answer: HBO has been associated with quality home entertainment for 50 years now. Max is just a word, and it's such a common word/name that it's not a great name for a product. Switching it b
u/Final7C
Answer: A few reasons. 1.) HBO is a well known IP, and Max is not. 2.) A company can only technically call something new for 6 months. Changing the name, gives the advertising people so
u/Duke_Tokem
I still call it Twitter, purely on childish spite for assuming Elon doesn't like it.
u/beezwhiz
should’ve been HBgO!
u/Knute5
I read Sergio Zyman's (the man behind New Coke) book "The End of Marketing as We Know It," and for all the outrage, New Coke did revive Coca Cola from a pure numbers perspective. I agree, th
u/Sarothu
Holy shit, I thought he was kidding, but [it's actually real](https://play.max.com/show/b23ac61e-0868-48b0-9491-5540879394ea).
u/MtNowhere
New Coke came out so Coca Cola could change the recipe of Coke without consumers tasting the difference so starkly. I hypothesize HBO Max was Max for a while so they could make streaming serv
u/BricksFriend
Maybe I was just in the right mindset but I swear that New Coke tasted better than Classic. Was kind of bummed when they dropped it.
u/screenaholic
And then when everyone hates New Slurm, we'll bring back Slurm Classic! Everyone will rush to buy it. And we'll make millions!
u/nsnyder
Answer: HBO is a beloved popular prestige brand. Max is... not.
u/MtNowhere
Cheaper original HBO Max will have us nostalgic and underwhelmed
u/Witch-Alice
Twitter and tweet had become common words. You literally can't buy that sort of brand awareness, it requires having a product that people use for years because they like it. Now how do peopl
u/Krazyguy75
I think I would be a great exec! I shall take a multimillion user social media platform and rename it Z and fire all the moderation team!
u/joenforcer
The New Coke formula actually lives on in Diet Coke. It still has the same color scheme and is distinct from Coke Zero, which is based on the Classic formula.
u/alliegal
Just spit out my soda reading Alaskan Bush People. Thank you.
u/addandsubtract
> I can only imagine enough people have been ~~fired~~ or consequences have been seen in focus groups *promoted
u/dew2459
McKinsey was in on that? No surprise. Customer: Oh mr consultant, how do I improve market share and profitability? McKinsey standard answer: rebrand and lay off half of your employees.
u/MtNowhere
New Coke came out so Coca Cola could change the recipe of Coke without consumers tasting the difference so starkly. I hypothesize HBO Max was Max for a while so they could make streaming serv
u/felipe_the_dog
That's why the name 'Acme' is such a trope.
u/nsnyder
Answer: HBO is a beloved popular prestige brand. Max is... not.
u/Knute5
Answer: Same reason Pizza Hut execs wanted to call it The Hut and fans got angry. Or when Coke tried to put out New Coke and people got angry. Execs change things because they want to make an
u/Tiramitsunami
Protip, in shortened decades the apostrophe goes on the other side because they are contractions: '70s.
u/wackocoal
well, at least they should have kept the "HBO" part... e.g. "HBO Discovery".          Even calling it "HBO Max" is way better than "Max".
u/ROADHOG_IS_MY_WAIFU
I remember back in the Xbox 360/Ps3 era, Netlfix app on PS3 had an assistant program called "Max" that would ask you questions about what you wanted to watch and then suggest a title for you.
u/MechaSandstar
IIRC, the estate of PG Wodehouse complained, and they had to.
u/GNOIZ1C
That depends! If you're a Nazi, you call it X. Otherwise, it's still Twitter.
u/229-northstar
They contracted it out so they can say the contractor told us to do that. We were just following their advice.. plausible deniability
u/fptackle
Bachelor Chow, now with flavor!
u/Uphoria
Hilariously Ask Jeeves eventually rebranded as Ask.com.
u/The_Razielim
>Now how do people refer to the site? I genuinely find it hilarious that most journalism always points to it as "X (fka Twitter)"
u/CHESTER_C0PPERP0T
It’s like Google merging with Ask Jeeves and calling it Jeeves. Decades of prestige and brand equity out the door. Fucking idiotic decision to call it “Max”. Probably saved someone a few mill
u/TooMuchPowerful
Such a dumb decision it could have only been made by a top level executive that no one could say no to. Anyone else would have been laughed out of the room.
u/SigmundFreud
I would totally watch a show about Sarah Palin and George Bush being best friends and going on adventures.
u/nerdforest
Do you remember when google tried to make a social media? Google circles or something. Mad stuff.
u/SellingFirewood
Supposedly HBO had decades of "quality content" to their name, and executives didn't want the trashy dating and reality shows they were releasing to taint the "HBO" image. Thus they dropped
u/Coollogin
>It’s like Google merging with Ask Jeeves and calling it Jeeves. Or replacing Twitter, which had already become both a verb, a noun, and variations (e.g., sub-tweet), with a letter.
u/According-Way9438
Imagine the focus groups, studies and money companies put into changing their brand just to be told to get fucked by the consumer
u/screenaholic
And then when everyone hates New Slurm, we'll bring back Slurm Classic! Everyone will rush to buy it. And we'll make millions!
u/RandomRageNet
No basically they're re-splitting WB/HBO and Discover but this time the Turner networks are going with Discover.
u/MtNowhere
Cheaper original HBO Max will have us nostalgic and underwhelmed
u/Deanobaby100
I like to think Conan O'Brien shitting all over the name on his show helped a lot..."It's on MAX, not HBO who cares about a legendary brand"
u/scarabic
Marketing is like HR. Anyone of any talent will wind up in some other department, any other department, doing any other fucking thing besides marketing.
u/CHESTER_C0PPERP0T
It’s like Google merging with Ask Jeeves and calling it Jeeves. Decades of prestige and brand equity out the door. Fucking idiotic decision to call it “Max”. Probably saved someone a few mill
u/FromAbyss
Did you actually lose it? Here in Brazil we had the same deal, but the name changes didn't have any effect on the lifetime offer (except for the price hikes).
u/ridemooses
And McKinsey. It’s always MocKinsey.
u/229-northstar
That is exactly why businesses use consultants. That way, when the project fails, the management team In charge is not held accountable
u/Krazyguy75
Brand recognition is so important that when someone was literally murdering people with repackaged Tylenol, they would rather entirely redo their packaging and put tons of warnings and infome
u/sgtmattie
It’s like they never even heard the words “search engine optimization.” The amount of brain dead branding that I’ve seen where clearly the people in charge never thought “what will happen if
u/GalinDray
Answer: You can get shockingly high up in Marketing at a large company and still be rock fucking stupid. In May 2023, Discovery and HBO Max merged and became the streaming service Max, dropp
u/Atilim87
Twitter is a better example. Twitter value lies in its name mostly…changing that to X is something only somebody that’s functioning on drugs would do….:ohhhhhh
u/The_bruce42
It was such a dumb decision to move away from it in the first place.
u/Uphoria
There is no deeper reason op. Everyone mocked them for going to just Max because of this reason, and now they're clawing it back. 
u/LazloNibble
Imagine how Artie from *The Larry Sanders Show* might react to this discussion!
u/ridemooses
And McKinsey. It’s always MocKinsey.
u/t_katkot
I always thought it was to protect the prestige of the HBO brand. The older iterations of HBO Max/Go were primarily focused on HBO original programming. When they added all of the Discover
u/uuggehor
Just thinking about HBO, and Oz intro starts playing in my head.
u/floataway3
I recall John Oliver was ripping into it as well on LWT the entire time.
u/LambCHOP6988
I dunno. I have fondler memories of Skinemax.
u/natfutsock
I'd've taken a $30 gas card from the get go to let them know this was a bad idea. Kept saying as much.
u/Uphoria
Hilariously Ask Jeeves eventually rebranded as Ask.com.
u/Ki11igraphy
I swear i read recently , WB/HBO is splitting into 2 separate entities and one will focus on the streaming and orgnal tv* development and the other live sports and something else.
u/Friscogonewild
Parents who grew up in an era where a TV app called "Max" probably reminded them more of ~~Skinemax~~ Cinemax, which was basically HBO but with more boobs and cursing? Doesn't make a lot of
u/hohihohi
Funny enough, the streaming service they had prior to HBO Max was HBO Go.
u/TooMuchPowerful
Such a dumb decision it could have only been made by a top level executive that no one could say no to. Anyone else would have been laughed out of the room.
u/Lou_Garoup
HBO and Warner Bros paid consultants a shitload of money that initially recommended changing the name to HBOMax after a merger and then a few years later they paid consultants a shitload of m
u/Weary-Cartoonist2630
There should be a sub for these kinds of low stakes yet completely nonsensical conspiracy theories
u/GalinDray
Answer: You can get shockingly high up in Marketing at a large company and still be rock fucking stupid. In May 2023, Discovery and HBO Max merged and became the streaming service Max, dropp
u/poopshipdestroyer
They didn’t even try adding skinamax to their max branded offerings before weaseling back to hbo.
u/phareous
They were afraid discovery would ruin the HBO name so they named it Max, which was dumb
u/arkensto
I figure if Elon can deadname his kid, I can deadname his company.
u/Knute5
I read Sergio Zyman's (the man behind New Coke) book "The End of Marketing as We Know It," and for all the outrage, New Coke did revive Coca Cola from a pure numbers perspective. I agree, th
u/bfeils
Answer: It’s actually not about switching back to the legacy branding as much as it is about their plans for next year. Warner Brothers Discovery is planning to split next year into a cable n
u/Infamous_Alpaca
It was a cool trick to get rid of those of us in the Nordics who received a lifetime half-price offer for subscribing.
u/Xeorm124
Which always struck me as silly. Why is the C suite hiring professionals when they're supposed to be the professionals. They always hate it when employees subcontract their work out. Another
u/Standup_Citizen
Nailed it with the confusion part. People will get over a name change eventually, but confusion means they stop buying. "Wanna get some Hut and watch a show on Max?" "Uh maybe? Idk what tho
u/Knute5
HBO (Home Box Office for old farts) harkens back to the advent of cable TV and there's memories and affinity around HBO. None around Max. Max sounds like an agency, an exec, etc. trying to
u/hmiser
Or renaming twitter. Having a good brand name or logo is like winning the lottery and renaming Mercedes Benz to Pontiac would be like throwing the ticket away.
u/MysteryBagIdeals
Both could absolutely be true -- you don't want to sully the HBO brand with low-quality garbage, you don't want to sully the Discovery brand with sex and violence, if you're going to combine
u/According-Way9438
Imagine the focus groups, studies and money companies put into changing their brand just to be told to get fucked by the consumer
u/percypersimmon
Also they have paid a consulting firm several hundred million dollars to tell them to change the name and then to change it back again.
u/FridayMcNight
The way I learned it was that the reason you hire McKinsey to write a report recommending whatever strategy pivot you already decided on is that you can say *you did what the experts recommen
u/Weary-Cartoonist2630
There should be a sub for these kinds of low stakes yet completely nonsensical conspiracy theories

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started