Compact, Legally-Compliant Discreet Carry Knives

Analysis: The user is clearly happy with their acquisition of a discontinued knife (Civivi Lumi), particularly because its design makes it ideal for carrying in places where having a knife is generally frowned upon. This suggests a strong demand for knives that are both discreet and legally compliant, especially when popular models are no longer available.

Product/Service Opportunity: There's a consistent demand for knives that are:

  1. Legally Compliant: Designed to meet or be ambiguous enough to comply with strict knife laws in various regions (e.g., blade length, locking mechanism, overall appearance).
  2. Discreet/Non-threatening Profile: Compact, slim, and with an unassuming aesthetic suitable for everyday carry (EDC) without drawing unwanted attention.
  3. High Utility for Size: Despite being compact, the knife should still offer good cutting performance and ergonomics for common tasks.

Specific Product Suggestion: Develop a new line of folding knives, or a specific model, focused on "Legally Discreet Carry."

  • Key Features:
    • Blade length under commonly accepted legal limits (e.g., under 3 inches or specific regional metrics like 7.62 cm).
    • Non-locking or a legally permissible locking mechanism (e.g., slipjoint, friction folder, or a detent-based mechanism that isn't considered a "true" lock in some jurisdictions).
    • Slim profile for comfortable pocket carry.
    • Unobtrusive pocket clip (deep carry preferred).
    • Materials that offer good value and performance (e.g., D2, 14C28N steel; G10, Micarta, or lightweight aluminum handles).
    • A design aesthetic that is more utilitarian or "gentlemanly" rather than tactical or aggressive.
  • Marketing Angle: Emphasize "Global EDC," "Travel-Friendly" (where permissible), or "Urban Discreet Carry."

Expected Benefit:

  • Targeted Niche Market: Address the needs of a specific segment of the EDC community facing legal restrictions or preferring discretion. This includes individuals in countries with strict laws, or professionals in environments where an overt knife is inappropriate.
  • Filling a Market Gap: Capitalize on the discontinuation of popular models like the Civivi Lumi that served this niche.
  • Brand Loyalty: A well-executed product that meets these specific, often underserved, needs can create strong brand loyalty.
  • Steady Sales Potential: While a niche, it's a persistent one. Sales can be driven through online knife retailers, EDC specialty shops, and direct-to-consumer channels.
  • Potential for Product Line Expansion: If successful, the line could be expanded with different blade shapes, materials, or slight variations while adhering to the core "legally discreet" concept.
  • Estimated Revenue: Difficult to quantify without market size data, but niche markets can be profitable if product development and marketing are efficient. A successful model could generate significant revenue, especially if it becomes a "go-to" for this specific need, similar to how the Lumi was for the user. Given the enthusiasm for a discontinued model, a well-priced successor (e.g., $50-$100 price range) could achieve thousands of units in sales annually.

Origin Reddit Post

r/knifeclub

Civivi Lumi, finally got my hands on a new discontinued Lumi

Posted by u/MarcusMaximius05/30/2025
It has for 2 years been always my most used knife…it’s profile makes it perfect to carry in a country where carrying a knife it’s a big no no… happy to get a new one before they completely di

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started