Consultancy: Employee motivation & flexible compensation for small machine shops.

A small machine shop owner, struggling with the unpredictable nature of their business, asks directly, "What motivates machinists?" This question shows they're looking for effective ways to keep their team engaged, especially during busy periods that require extra hours and weekend work. The conversation reveals that machinists value financial incentives like better overtime rates and bonuses, good benefits, substantial paid time off, and respectful treatment. They often dismiss low-value gestures like "pizza parties."

This presents a clear opportunity for a Specialized Consultancy Service for Small Manufacturing Businesses.

Service Description: This service would partner with small machine shop owners to develop, implement, and refine tailored employee motivation and retention programs that address the cyclical demands of the industry. Key offerings would include:

  1. Incentive Program Design:

    • Crafting flexible and attractive compensation structures, including tiered overtime pay, shift differentials, and performance-based bonuses (e.g., quarterly profit-sharing, project completion bonuses, quality adherence incentives).
    • Advising on competitive benefits packages (health, retirement) and impactful paid time off (PTO) policies.
  2. Non-Monetary Reward Strategy:

    • Developing meaningful recognition programs that go beyond superficial gestures, focusing on personalized rewards, additional PTO, or skill development opportunities based on employee feedback and proven successes.
  3. Implementation & Communication Support:

    • Assisting owners in effectively communicating new incentive programs to their teams to ensure buy-in and transparency.
    • Providing frameworks for gathering employee feedback to continuously adapt and improve motivation strategies.
  4. Culture Enhancement:

    • Guidance on fostering a work environment where employees feel valued and respected, directly impacting their willingness to contribute during peak times.

Expected Benefits for the Machine Shop:

  • Increased Employee Motivation and Productivity: Particularly during crucial "feast" periods and for overtime/weekend shifts.
  • Improved Employee Retention: Reducing costly turnover of skilled machinists by addressing their core motivational needs.
  • Enhanced Ability to Attract Talent: Becoming known as an employer that fairly compensates and values its workforce.
  • More Stable and Reliable Workforce: Helping to smooth out the operational challenges of a "feast or famine" business cycle.
  • Reduced Owner Stress: By providing proven strategies to manage workforce engagement effectively.
  • Higher Overall Profitability: Through increased output, efficiency, and reduced employee churn.

Origin Reddit Post

r/machinists

What motivates machinists?

Posted by u/Impressive_Dirt_669305/30/2025
I am a typical small machine shop owner and one thing I've observed over the years is that machines shops are feast or famine. When you are slow it feels like the walls are closing in. When y

Top Comments

u/Fififaggetti
Been on the shit end of that stick oh and gots keep machines running while you eat
u/SonOfDirtFarmer
We talkin' Ruger 10-22 or an M1A here?
u/DixieNormas011
Had a boss take us all (6 man small shop) to the outdoor sports store in town and pick out a rifle after a 3 month stretch of long hours. Not as good as a fat bonus check but was still prett
u/Repulsive_Chef_972
Caffeine, nicotine, sugar, salt, grease, and alcohol. Basically, all of the adult food groups.
u/Teamhank
How about a cook out 😀😉? 🤡
u/Theplaidiator
The repair shop I work in gives a bonus to everyone equal to an extra 40 hours on their paycheck if the quarterly gross profit quota is met. It absolutely motivates people to hit goals and el
u/redjohn79
What would motivate people to work weekends? More money. Simple as that.
u/Superb-Fix-4405
I owned a shop with 24 employees and know exactly your pain. What i found out that helped was motivation. I would tell them if the jobs was completed by Thursday they could go home early th
u/Jorvall
I'm probably an exception because my wife makes like 4x what I do. I like the puzzles. Some weird ass part that isnt made anymore for some defunct airplane or lawnmower that I have to backw
u/SonOfDirtFarmer
Hell yeah, love my Mini
u/skip-bo
Our shop is having a bbq next month and the night shift guys get off at 4am to come in for noon the next day. Day shift gets the rest of the day off and beer is being served but the night shi
u/spaceman_spyff
Increase O/T rate or add a shift differential to hours worked outside normal shifts. If you want to defer payouts so you don’t have such huge payroll burden you could increase the PTO accrual
u/rotcivwg
I’m 34 and one of the top guys in my shop. I straight up told the owner I won’t work overtime. There is nothing that would motivate me to do it, especially not on the weekends.
u/brian0066600
You’re idea that people value their time more than money is inaccurate, it’s just most people don’t get paid enough to flip the priorities. You pay everyone $300 an hour you’ll see people wil
u/DixieNormas011
Somewhere in between. Mini-14 I still use to hunt Coyotes with
u/Sullypants1
Money
u/BluKab00se
Money and monetary bonuses. Also cold hard cash. 
u/WotanSpecialist
This is a bot account making a bait post, if you weren’t aware.
u/Fififaggetti
Money, if your making money they should too. vacation and stability Pizza parties are an outright kick in the nuts.
u/zara2355
Yeah, its money. People want to feed their families and money is what does that
u/Traditional-Type182
Money is the answer. Just giving the standard time and a half for overtime isn’t always gonna be enough. Start giving bonuses every six months that are based on a handful of things, one of wh
u/Fififaggetti
Only if it’s mandatory on your day off.
u/AyahaushaAaronRodger
That’s dope I’m jealous haha. The shop I’m at for quarterly stuff they give out two yeti coolers, personalized coffee mugs for machinist of the months and machinist of the quarter as well as
u/AyahaushaAaronRodger
Money and OT money. Quarterly bonuses for everyone if quotas are meant. Save the stupid ass pizza parties and bullshit “awards” and give everyone something they actually want which again is m
u/Joebranflakes
2. Benefits that don’t suck 3. Decent amount of paid vacation time 4. Some retirement contribution benefit.

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started