Content Strategy: Balancing Familiarity and Novelty for Audience Engagement

Published on 07/22/2025Trend Spotting / Early Adopter Signals

This study's finding that fanfiction communities crave familiarity but enjoy novelty more is a critical insight for all content creators and marketers. It identifies a core psychological tension in audience engagement. Opportunities exist in: 1. Content development: Brands and creators can strategically design products, stories, or services that leverage familiar elements (e.g., brand identity, established characters, genre tropes) while introducing innovative or surprising twists to maximize enjoyment. 2. Algorithmic recommendations: Platforms (streaming, e-commerce, social media) can refine recommendation engines to suggest content that strikes this optimal balance between known preferences and fresh experiences. 3. Marketing messaging: Campaigns can be crafted to explicitly highlight how a product offers both comfort and excitement, appealing to this dual desire. 4. User-generated content platforms: Designing features that encourage creators to innovate within established frameworks, or tools that help users discover 'familiar yet novel' content.

Origin Reddit Post

r/science

Study finds fanfiction community craves familiarity more than novelty, but also reports that they find greater enjoyment from novelty. Future work may identify ways to establish link between

Posted by u/drewiepoodle07/22/2025

Top Comments

u/Talentagentfriend
Novelty is for the memes. Familiarity is for that itch. 
u/TWVer
I hate sand. That said, I can see there being a disconnect between a self reported desire for novelty vs a measured desire for more familiarity instead. People are creatures of habit and pe
u/Talentagentfriend
Novelty is for the memes. Familiarity is for that itch. 
u/WagTheKat
We want new stories about the places and characters we love. Or new characters that fit those places we love. 
u/WagTheKat
We want new stories about the places and characters we love. Or new characters that fit those places we love. 
u/lanternhead
We must optimize the novelty:familiarity ratios of our entertainment by using LLMs to generate the maximally profitable prequel reboot crossovers 
u/lanternhead
We must optimize the novelty:familiarity ratios of our entertainment by using LLMs to generate the maximally profitable prequel reboot crossovers 
u/Talentagentfriend
Novelty is for the memes. Familiarity is for that itch. 
u/[deleted]
[deleted]
u/WagTheKat
We want new stories about the places and characters we love. Or new characters that fit those places we love. 
u/TWVer
I hate sand. That said, I can see there being a disconnect between a self reported desire for novelty vs a measured desire for more familiarity instead. People are creatures of habit and pe

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started