House Flipper Fails: How to Spot and Fix Shoddy Renovation Work

Recurring Problems/Confusions Identified:

  1. Spotting Shoddy Flipper Work: Homeowners are constantly uncovering subpar craftsmanship in flipped houses, often hidden or covered up (like joint compound over fluted molding or cheap materials replacing original quality).

  2. Restoration vs. Replacement Dilemma: Users grapple with whether to restore damaged or covered original features (like molding) or if it's better to replace them entirely. There's a desire to preserve the original character, but uncertainty about the effort and skill required.

  3. Identifying Original Features vs. Flipper Additions: Confusion about what is original to the house versus what the flipper installed poorly (e.g., bad veneer work, cheap baseboards).

  4. Understanding "Why" Flippers Make Certain Choices: Users are baffled by flippers covering up desirable features or making questionable aesthetic choices (e.g., "bad taste, too much HGTV," painting trim black, using the cheapest possible materials).

  5. Practical How-To for Repairs/Restoration: Users are looking for guidance on how to fix flipper mistakes, like stripping paint/compound from molding or properly installing trim.

Content Ideas with Viral Potential:


Content Idea 1: "The Flipper's 'Fix' Files: Exposing Common Shortcuts & How to Really Repair Them"

  • Concept: A series (video, blog posts, social media carousels) that highlights common shortcuts flippers take and then provides a step-by-step guide on how to properly repair or restore the feature. This taps into the "exposing bad work" drama and offers valuable DIY advice.
  • Example Content Schemes:
    • Video/Reel: "Flipper Fail #1: Molding Massacre!"
      • Visual: Show fluted molding covered in joint compound (the "flipper fix").
      • Narrative: "Did your flipper do this? They thought covering original detail was easier. Here’s how to undo it."
      • DIY Guide: Quick cuts showing careful scraping, sanding (mentioning products like Citristrip if applicable), and revealing the original detail. End with a beautifully restored section.
    • Blog Post/Carousel: "5 Flipper Shortcuts Hiding in Your 'Renovated' Home (And How to Fix Them)"
      • Shortcut 1: The Joint Compound Cover-Up (Molding): Before/After, tools needed, step-by-step restoration.
      • Shortcut 2: The 'Paint Everything' Special (Hinges, Outlets): How to properly remove, clean/replace, and repaint.
      • Shortcut 3: Cheap Flooring Over Hardwood: How to check, remove, and potentially refinish original floors.
      • Shortcut 4: Badly Installed Veneer/Backsplash: Signs of poor installation (uneven, wrong adhesive), and when to call a pro vs. DIY.
      • Shortcut 5: Ignoring Proper Prep Work: Showing how flippers skip priming or sanding, leading to peeling paint, and how to do it right.
  • Target Audience:
    • New homeowners of flipped houses.
    • DIY enthusiasts.
    • People currently house hunting and wary of flips.
    • Real estate followers interested in home improvement fails and wins.
  • Why it could be viral: The "reveal" or "exposure" aspect is inherently shareable. Practical, actionable advice empowers homeowners. Before/after transformations are visually satisfying.

Content Idea 2: "Is It Salvageable? A Homeowner's Guide to Restoring Original Features After a Flip"

  • Concept: This content addresses the "restore or replace" dilemma. It helps homeowners assess whether an original feature compromised by a flipper (like molding, doors, hardware, or even floors) is worth the effort to restore, and provides guidance on how to approach different restoration projects.
  • Example Content Schemes:
    • Quiz/Flowchart (Interactive or Static): "Should You Restore or Replace That Flipper-Damaged Feature?"
      • Questions: Is it truly original? What's its condition under the flipper's 'fix'? How much time/budget do you have? What's your DIY skill level? Is the feature rare/valuable?
    • Video Series: "Restoration Realities: Saving Original Charm"
      • Episode 1: Uncovering Fluted Molding: Focus on techniques, tools (Citristrip, scrapers, sanders), and patience required. Show the satisfying reveal.
      • Episode 2: Giving Old Doors New Life: Stripping paint, repairing damage, finding period-appropriate hardware.
      • Episode 3: The Great Hardware Hunt: Where to find salvaged hardware, how to clean it.
    • Article: "Don't Demolish, Restore! How to Decide if Your Home's Original Details Are Worth Saving from a Bad Flip." Includes expert tips on identifying value and common restoration challenges.
  • Target Audience:
    • Homeowners of older homes that have been flipped.
    • DIYers interested in preservation and detailed craft.
    • Individuals feeling overwhelmed by a flip and looking for guidance on where to start.
  • Why it could be viral: Taps into the emotional connection people have with older homes and original character. Offers hope and practical solutions for seemingly "ruined" features. Satisfying transformation stories.

Content Idea 3: "Decoding Flipper Logic: Why They Did THAT (and What It REALLY Means for Your House)"

  • Concept: This content aims to explain the common (often frustrating and seemingly illogical) decisions flippers make, framing it from their perspective (speed, cost-cutting) and then explaining the actual implications for the homeowner. It combines a bit of industry insight with practical warnings.
  • Example Content Schemes:
    • Short Explainer Videos (TikTok/Reels):
      • "Why Flippers Paint Everything Grey: It's not (just) HGTV, it's about appealing to the widest, quickest buyer pool. But what does it hide?"
      • "The Truth About LVP (Luxury Vinyl Plank): Why flippers love it (cheap, easy, covers sins) and what you should check underneath!"
      • "Joint Compound Over Detail: The ultimate lazy fix. Why they do it (time = money) and the damage it can cause."
    • Article/Infographic: "The Flipper's Triangle: Cheap, Fast, or Good (They Can Only Pick Two!)." Illustrates common trade-offs flippers make.
      • Example: Covering original molding: Fast & Cheap chosen. Good (preserving detail) ignored. Implication for homeowner: Loss of character, potential difficulty in restoration.
      • Example: Lowest-bid contractor for tile: Cheap chosen. Fast maybe. Good (proper waterproofing, level tiles) often ignored. Implication for homeowner: Future leaks, expensive repairs.
    • "Ask a (Reformed) Flipper" Segment: Q&A addressing common homeowner questions about flipper choices.
  • Target Audience:
    • Frustrated homeowners trying to understand the state of their flipped house.
    • Prospective homebuyers wanting to be more informed.
    • Anyone interested in the realities of the house flipping market.
  • Why it could be viral: Offers a "behind-the-scenes" look. Validates homeowners' frustrations. Can be humorous or shocking, making it shareable. Empowers buyers with knowledge.

Origin Reddit Post

r/diy

Flippers screwed me again: door frame edition

Posted by u/215bc06/11/2025
So we bought a flipped house a couple years back and it seems like I can’t go a week without discovering some new example of shoddy craftsmanship. The latest is on the front door frame. It lo

Top Comments

u/215bc
We also had to rip out the “finished basement” because of water issues. And then spent 30k we were going to use to build a patio on French drains and refinishing the flooring and drywall.
u/Sunsunsunsunsunsun
My whole house had hardwood floors and nice colonial wood baseboards. They replaced it all with plank vinyl and MDF square baseboards, literally the cheapest you can buy at home Depot. The
u/stormpilgrim
Watching First Time Flippers was always kinda terrifying and saddening. "Oh, going with the laminated particle board cabinet doors. Great choice. The new owners will just love that in six mon
u/Get_Your_Schwift_On
Fypon looks as good as wood when primed and painted and will last 20-40 years (at least). Modern wood sucks compared to the old growth stuff. Especially since you can't seal with lead paint
u/Queasy_Local_7199
Notice the basic modern aesthetic th why would you replace them? He’d have to spend more Money and end up with much shittier quality product. A flipper would replace, homeowner would restore
u/ferroequine
For the same reason they painted the trim black. Bad taste, too much HGTV.
u/Hiking-Miked
That’s when you say you’ll take all his “trash” so he doesn’t need to fill a dumpster!
u/Inquisitor_ForHire
Right? And the Romans weren't dropping dead from it! They all lived long healthy lives and died at the ripe old age of 37.
u/NishieP
Craftsmanship just isnt appreciated anymore its so sad. My neighbor had this beautiful home built in the late 1800s. Paid THOUSANDS to take all the original baseboards and trim out. Removed t
u/dorsalispedis
That’s called fluted molding. Did you want the flutes back? That would be quite painful to make look right. It would probably be easier to pry the old trim off and put new molding on if that’
u/skintigh
Lead paint doesn't have metallic lead in it, it uses lead oxide powder as the white base, Modern paint uses titanium oxide. If lead paint were really flashing then titanium paint would be arm
u/sublliminali
It’s not hard to reproduce today. You can buy this at Lowe’s (I have). Not trying to degrade the general sentiment that a lot of complicated ornamental woodwork is a lost art and hard to
u/Get_Your_Schwift_On
Fypon looks as good as wood when primed and painted and will last 20-40 years (at least). Modern wood sucks compared to the old growth stuff. Especially since you can't seal with lead paint
u/cullcanyon
The corner edges on the veneer looks terrible. The angles don’t match and they filled it in with silicone.
u/ntyperteasy
I’d replace them. They are called Pilasters. Real wood if you’re particular or Fypon if functional is good enough. https://fypon.com/pages/window-and-door-trim If it’s not a standard siz
u/ntyperteasy
I’d replace them. They are called Pilasters. Real wood if you’re particular or Fypon if functional is good enough. https://fypon.com/pages/window-and-door-trim If it’s not a standard siz
u/NishieP
Craftsmanship just isnt appreciated anymore its so sad. My neighbor had this beautiful home built in the late 1800s. Paid THOUSANDS to take all the original baseboards and trim out. Removed t
u/solthar
There's an old industrial office that one of my clients rented. They asked for and received permission to repaint the office before they moved in. In writing. They then proceeded to pai
u/Hiking-Miked
Why would you cover up the fluted molding?!!? It’s so nice, authentic and hard to reproduce today! I’d take it on as a side project to restore to bring back the historic authenticity to your
u/Hiking-Miked
Why would you cover up the fluted molding?!!? It’s so nice, authentic and hard to reproduce today! I’d take it on as a side project to restore to bring back the historic authenticity to your
u/dorsalispedis
That’s called fluted molding. Did you want the flutes back? That would be quite painful to make look right. It would probably be easier to pry the old trim off and put new molding on if that’
u/slicehardware
I used [Citristrip](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CL5JQCMS/ref=cm_sw_r_as_gl_api_gl_i_M1YK2HYFKR066PHMMCFX?linkCode=ml1&tag=slicehardwa05-20) with decent results to strip latex paint from m
u/sublliminali
It’s not hard to reproduce today. You can buy this at Lowe’s (I have). Not trying to degrade the general sentiment that a lot of complicated ornamental woodwork is a lost art and hard to
u/Macgrubersblaupunkt
Thats the sad state these days. Flippers but also honest folks trying to keep up with home prices. They want to maximize value because the place theyre trying to buy is also overvalued. Do
u/Get_Your_Schwift_On
No shit it's toxic. White Lead is highly water insoluble, therefore lead based paints are moisture resistant. It's also flexible and crack resistant far longer than other paints and it can g
u/egnards
Dude I feel you - We bought a flipped house 2 years ago. . . * Several pieces of brand new siding have literally just fallen off * We had to rip up the entire "brand new" basement because of
u/DesolationRobot
It probably would have been easier for the flippers to just pry it up and replace it with a flat board if they didn’t want the flutes. Crazy that they filled it up with pounds of joint compou
u/DesolationRobot
It probably would have been easier for the flippers to just pry it up and replace it with a flat board if they didn’t want the flutes. Crazy that they filled it up with pounds of joint compou
u/Blueskyminer
That fake stone wasn't your first giveaway this was a flip?
u/Sunsunsunsunsunsun
My whole house had hardwood floors and nice colonial wood baseboards. They replaced it all with plank vinyl and MDF square baseboards, literally the cheapest you can buy at home Depot. The
u/ferroequine
For the same reason they painted the trim black. Bad taste, too much HGTV.
u/Dramatic_Explosion
One of the reasons romans added lead to cheap wine was to sweeten it. Wild to think so much of their society regularly consumed lead.
u/tmstout
While I love blaming modern problems on climate change as much as the next guy, I don’t think it’s the primary driver here. Old growth wood is essentially a non-renewable resource due to it
u/duder43
Is it me or does the stone veneer not look right either? Doesn't looked installed correctly and could have some unusual moisture issues too. OP, how are the walls inside the home?
u/rimeswithburple
Yeah. But lead paint chips tasted a LOT better. Kind of a sweet aftertaste.
u/Hiking-Miked
That’s when you say you’ll take all his “trash” so he doesn’t need to fill a dumpster!
u/GreatestStarOfAll
I had an acquaintance in New York who was trying to renovate a gorgeous 1900s three-story home and was looking to hire someone to tear up and replace the flooring with laminate tile. Every
u/TheCoolOnesGotTaken
And the details -long vertical rounded grooves - are called flutes so this is a fluted pilaster.
u/PolarSquirrelBear
I could start a show called, “This Fucking House” for our house.
u/RichestTeaPossible
Lads, I’ve found RFK. Attack!

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started