Modular Bath System: Flexible Shower/Tub Solution for Single-Bath Homes, Boosts Resale.

Product/Service Opportunity Analysis:

1. Identified Need/Problem: The Reddit discussion highlights a common challenge for homeowners with a single full bathroom: deciding between a walk-in shower (preferred by some for daily use and modern aesthetics) or a bathtub (often seen as essential for resale value, families with young children, pet owners, and practical uses like washing large items). Users want the best of both worlds but are limited by space and the potential impact on future home sales. Phrases like "come time to sell," "hurt resale," "needed the tub for kids," and using tubs for "pets" or "washing things" clearly show this tension.

2. Proposed Product/Service: A "Hybrid Hideaway Bath System" or "Convertible Shower-to-Tub Module."

This system would primarily function as a sleek, modern walk-in shower with a low or zero threshold. The key innovation would be an integrated or easily attachable/deployable tub component.

  • Design Concept:
    • Shower Base: A spacious, non-slip shower pan with efficient drainage, possibly with built-in seating or niches.
    • Deployable Tub: A lightweight yet durable tub basin (e.g., made from reinforced acrylic, composite, or a high-grade inflatable material with a rigid frame) that can be:
      • Folded/Collapsed: Stored vertically against a wall within the shower enclosure (disguised as a decorative panel) or easily removed and stored in a nearby closet.
      • Raised/Lowered: A more integrated system where a shallow tub basin mechanically or manually raises from the shower floor or lowers from a concealed wall compartment to form a functional tub.
      • Modular Insert: A precisely fitting, sturdy insert that can be quickly placed into the shower area and sealed to create a watertight tub.
    • Sealing Mechanism: A robust, user-friendly sealing system to ensure no leaks when the tub component is deployed.
    • Aesthetics: Designed to look intentional and high-quality in both shower and tub configurations.

3. Target Users:

  • Homeowners with single-bathroom homes undergoing renovation.
  • Owners of small apartments or condos where space optimization is crucial.
  • Individuals or couples who primarily shower but want the option of a tub for occasional use (soaking, guests with children, pet bathing).
  • Property developers or flippers aiming to maximize the appeal of small properties to a wider range of buyers.

4. Expected Benefits & Value Proposition:

  • Solves the "Tub vs. Shower" Dilemma: Offers the daily convenience and modern appeal of a walk-in shower with the practical benefits and resale reassurance of a bathtub.
  • Space Efficiency: Maximizes usable space in small bathrooms by not having a permanent, bulky tub if it's not frequently used for bathing.
  • Increased Property Value/Appeal: Makes homes with single bathrooms more attractive to a broader range of potential buyers (families with young children, individuals who enjoy baths, pet owners) without alienating those who prefer showers.
  • Versatility: Caters to multiple needs – quick showers, relaxing baths, bathing children, washing pets, soaking large items.
  • Modern Aesthetics: Provides a contemporary bathroom design.
  • Potential for Aging-in-Place: A low-threshold shower is accessible, and a deployable tub could be designed for easier entry/exit than a traditional deep tub.

5. Potential Revenue Streams/Market Approach:

  • Direct Sales to Consumers: Via home improvement stores, online retailers, and direct-to-consumer channels.
  • Partnerships with Contractors/Remodelers: Offer the system as a premium option for bathroom renovations.
  • Collaboration with Home Builders: For inclusion in new constructions, especially in compact urban dwellings.
  • Estimated Price Point: Premium to a standard walk-in shower installation, but potentially less than a full separate tub and shower renovation, justifying the value through versatility and enhanced resale potential. The novelty and problem-solving nature could command a higher margin.
  • Marketing: Focus on the "best of both worlds" aspect, space-saving benefits, and appeal to homeowners concerned about resale value. Highlight ease of conversion and durability.

Origin Reddit Post

r/homeimprovement

Taking a poll Bath or shower???

Posted by u/Formal-Mountain-605205/28/2025
Im looking at a bathroom remodel in my single full bath home. Theres a tub/shower that we only shower in. I was thinking of a walk in shower but a friend says come time to sell, 3-5 years, i

Top Comments

u/IntelligentArgument8
I use the tub all the time to wash things. Every house should have a tub. It’s a multipurpose utility tool.
u/shroomie19
I rarely take a bath but I use my tub to bathe my pets. I'd think some people would want one if they have little kids right?
u/GullibleDetective
This is how my parents are setup. Though the tub room is a tub/w surround and shower
u/DescriptionOne8197
Bathtubs are good for people with small children so it can hurt resale. With that said I haven’t taking a bath myself since I was a child so I’m also considering eliminating ours. We consider
u/chnsuzzz
After 20 years i used my big tub maybe 5 times. Use my oversized shower twice a day. Finally duh. It just gathered junk. Ripped it out, fixed flooring. Got a set of ikea cabinets that look
u/stggold
Shower over a fiberglass tub/shower. Usually a well done walk in sells better than a basic tub/shower.
u/kimbochisan
Bathtub here. I'm an adult but I enjoy taking hot baths from time to time and especially when I'm not feeling well or it's insanely cold outside. I don't have kids but a tub helps me wash my
u/Waffles-McGee
If you’re planning to sell in the next few years, bath for sure. A standing shower only will turn off families and people who like baths
u/somebodyistrying
When we had small kids we absolutely needed the tub but now we only take showers. That being said we are remodeling the bathroom with the tub and are getting a new tub since we’ve heard the s
u/Up2nogud13
I mainly shower, but enjoy a good long soak now and again. We have a standalone shower and a garden tub in the master, and a claw foot with a shower kit in the "regular" bathroom.
u/just_me_steve
Some women just like to soak in a hot bath. My experience after I installed a shower downstairs for Dad to use in wheelchair I used the shower. After I broke my ankle, I couldn't get down st
u/jeffprop
Do what you want. You will please as many people as you displease. Every reason people tell you not to do it will have just as many from people telling you to do it.
u/Environmental-Low792
We are replacing our only tub with a walk in shower. The birth rate is going down and the population is aging, so the odds of someone with kids bidding on our house when we decide to sell is
u/Decisions_70
Must have a tub for resale. I'd 💯 walk away from a place without one.
u/hughflungpooh
It’s more important that you have a new bathroom. A beautiful walk in shower does not hurt resale.
u/appsteve
You must always have one bath. If you have two full bathrooms, then one can be a shower. This is the rule.
u/Old_gal4444
We only shower. We were going to do the same as you, but we watch the House Hunter shows and many people want a bath, so we are keeping a tub in one bathroom. The other has only a shower.
u/jimbosz07
This is debated a lot and I asked my very experienced agent. His take is that it doesn’t hurt your resale value but you will disqualify some buyers that need a tub
u/books-cats-plants
FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THINGS GOOD, DO NOT TAKE OUT THE BATH
u/MozzerellaStix
Funny we have a bath and shower and we shower our kids with us. Just find it easier.
u/Spartanfan56
You should have at least 1 bathtub in the house, even if you never take baths. If you had a 2 bathroom house then by all means make the master bath shower only.
u/zombiebacchus
I plan on staying in my house for at least 15 more years. It has 2 bathrooms. One currently has a tub but we are having it removed during our remodel for a large walk in shower. I fully expec
u/tallguy1755
Check code too. Where I live, if you have a full bath, you need to have a tub. If you have multiple full baths, you can put showers only or tub/shower combo in them. But the house has to have
u/Any-Entertainer9302
Both.  Tubs are endlessly useful.  
u/Notmyname525
As you get older, you may want to soak in the tub when you start to gets aches and pains from aging.

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started