Offer Design Feedback & Potential Cross-Promotion for EU Policy News Site
Okay, I've taken a look at the Reddit post.
Identified Potential Collaborator:
The main person for potential collaboration is the Original Poster (OP) of the Reddit thread 1l3zc8y
.
- Reasoning for Selection: The OP is actively working on a new project (an EU Digital Policy news site), is explicitly asking for feedback (logo critique), and is clearly responsive and open to suggestions from the community. For example, they said, "Yes, that's one of my worries, so I'm glad someone is confirming this. Will try to update this. Do you have any different font ideas?" and "Good to know, thanks for the feedback!" This shows they are likely to be receptive to collaboration offers.
Collaboration Suggestions & Expected Benefits:
-
Offer Advanced Design Critique & Concrete Solutions:
- Suggestion: Go beyond general feedback. Since the OP asked for font ideas and acknowledged concerns about the pixel art clashing with a "modern" feel, suggest specific font pairings that achieve a "serious and modern" aesthetic suitable for a news site. You could also propose alternative symbolic representations for "EU Digital Policy" that might be less niche than pixel art Europa, or explain how the current concept could be refined to better meet their goals. If you have design skills, a quick conceptual sketch of an alternative approach could be highly valuable.
- Expected Benefit: This establishes you as a knowledgeable and helpful resource in design or branding. It could lead to the OP valuing your input on future design or site development aspects, potentially acknowledging your contribution, or opening doors for other forms of collaboration once the site is live.
-
Propose Early User Testing & Content Feedback:
- Suggestion: Express genuine interest in the niche (EU Digital Policy). Offer to be an early beta-tester for the news site when it's ready. Commit to providing structured feedback not just on design, but also on user experience, content clarity, navigation, and overall site functionality from the perspective of a target user.
- Expected Benefit: This allows you to build a direct relationship with the creator and gain early insight into a new platform within your potential sphere of interest. For the creator, it provides invaluable pre-launch feedback. This can lead to opportunities for early contributor status, guest content features, or simply being recognized as a supportive community member, enhancing your own visibility within that niche.
-
Explore Niche-Specific Cross-Promotional or Content Opportunities (if applicable):
- Suggestion: If your own KOL activities align with EU policy, digital rights, journalism, or technology news, tentatively propose future collaboration. For example: "Once your site is launched, I'd be happy to explore sharing it with my audience interested in [relevant topic]," or "If you're looking for initial content or perspectives, I might be able to contribute an article/insight on [specific related subject]."
- Expected Benefit: This can lead to mutual audience growth and content enrichment. You gain a new platform or subject for your own content, and the creator gets early promotional support or valuable content. It positions you as a proactive and connected figure within the relevant community.
The key is to approach the OP with genuine offers of value that address their stated needs and demonstrate your expertise or interest in their project's domain.
Origin Reddit Post
r/design_critiques
Logo critique: does this capture the vibe for an EU Digital Policy news site?
Posted by u/anonboxis•06/05/2025
I'm building a news site for EU Digital Policy news. So, I want it to look somewhat serious and modern. The symbol is pixel art of Europa and the Bull and the text will be the name of the sit
Top Comments
u/anonboxis
Good to know, thanks for the feedback!
u/SabrinaHartford
What I like:
The bold simple look of the logo. The font seems professional and means business, so it's appropriate for the topic of policy.
What I would change:
The pixel art is a clev
u/PetitPxl
Came here to say the same - it looks great but the spacing on 'DIG IT AL' looks like three separate words - I get it though - Eurostile Extended is hard to space because the wider size exag
u/iGhostEdd
The font should match with the image or viceversa. You have a pixelated image (vintage and so) and if you ask me, the font remimds me of a police department from the future (or just modern).
u/VinRebelle
At a glance, I didn’t know what myth was being referenced, but it looks distinctly Ancient Greek to me and I think that’s a good idea, with Greece being seen (maybe wrongly, but certainly wid
u/iGhostEdd
The font should match with the image or viceversa. You have a pixelated image (vintage and so) and if you ask me, the font remimds me of a police department from the future (or just modern).
u/anonboxis
Yes that is one of my worries so I'm glad someone is confirming this. Will try to update this. Do you have any different font ideas?
u/pearstew
also, pay attention to kerning; the “T” and “A” are quite far apart from each other in this version :-)
u/creativegapmt
This was where my head went too; if the logo is 8 bit style, the logotype should follow suit and compliment it.
u/pearstew
also, pay attention to kerning; the “T” and “A” are quite far apart from each other in this version :-)
u/Notwerk
The pixelated art clashes with the modern, all-caps text. It looks like someone was making a retro game but couldn't decide whether it was farming sim or a space shooter. The Greek mythology
u/anonboxis
Thanks for doing this. Will work on something similar and maybe make alternatives and see what i prefer (might repost soon).
u/pearstew
my mind immediately went to something like [this](https://imgur.com/a/AZzDPqn) (very rough sketch, the scale is way off, obviously; but i hope it gets the idea across).
u/anonboxis
Yes that is one of my worries so I'm glad someone is confirming this. Will try to update this. Do you have any different font ideas?
u/Notwerk
The pixelated art clashes with the modern, all-caps text. It looks like someone was making a retro game but couldn't decide whether it was farming sim or a space shooter. The Greek mythology
u/Notwerk
The pixelated art clashes with the modern, all-caps text. It looks like someone was making a retro game but couldn't decide whether it was farming sim or a space shooter. The Greek mythology
u/PetitPxl
Came here to say the same - it looks great but the spacing on 'DIG IT AL' looks like three separate words - I get it though - Eurostile Extended is hard to space because the wider size exag
u/anonboxis
Thanks for doing this. Will work on something similar and maybe make alternatives and see what i prefer (might repost soon).
u/Alfakappa
the pixelated logo is sick, try to pick a font with the same vibe, or at least use it for some of the letters
u/justinpenner
This might be a cool idea. Everything pixelated might be confusing but perhaps the first letter in each word, and round the corners of the E to make the pixels obvious (it would also add a sl
u/pearstew
no problem at all, good luck! keep me posted :-)
u/anonboxis
Good to know, thanks for the feedback!
u/rjdesign
Since you are doing news you could try to find a pixelated gothic font.
Something like this:
https://www.dafont.com/alagard.font
u/anonboxis
Yes that is one of my worries so I'm glad someone is confirming this. Will try to update this. Do you have any different font ideas?
u/pearstew
my mind immediately went to something like [this](https://imgur.com/a/AZzDPqn) (very rough sketch, the scale is way off, obviously; but i hope it gets the idea across).
u/pearstew
also, pay attention to kerning; the “T” and “A” are quite far apart from each other in this version :-)
u/creativegapmt
This was where my head went too; if the logo is 8 bit style, the logotype should follow suit and compliment it.
u/rjdesign
Since you are doing news you could try to find a pixelated gothic font.
Something like this:
https://www.dafont.com/alagard.font
u/de-sombre
Have you considered using a glitch effect or a more modern design? While the pixel art is nice, I’m not certain that the retro style is the best way to represent EU Digital Policy. If your ne
u/justinpenner
Eurostile with janky kerning seems like a lazy choice, and it'll work against you in terms of memorability and standing out from other Europe-based organizations. I'd spend a little more time
u/VinRebelle
At a glance, I didn’t know what myth was being referenced, but it looks distinctly Ancient Greek to me and I think that’s a good idea, with Greece being seen (maybe wrongly, but certainly wid
u/justinpenner
Eurostile with janky kerning seems like a lazy choice, and it'll work against you in terms of memorability and standing out from other Europe-based organizations. I'd spend a little more time
u/SabrinaHartford
What I like:
The bold simple look of the logo. The font seems professional and means business, so it's appropriate for the topic of policy.
What I would change:
The pixel art is a clev
u/pearstew
i honestly really like the vibe you got going here. i like the pixelart a lot, looks great. however, i don’t think your composition is really working right now. i feel like it’s really missin
u/berdai1
Did you try some Grotesk typeface and only first letter Cap
u/pearstew
i honestly really like the vibe you got going here. i like the pixelart a lot, looks great. however, i don’t think your composition is really working right now. i feel like it’s really missin
u/anonboxis
Good to know, thanks for the feedback!
u/pearstew
i honestly really like the vibe you got going here. i like the pixelart a lot, looks great. however, i don’t think your composition is really working right now. i feel like it’s really missin
u/de-sombre
Have you considered using a glitch effect or a more modern design? While the pixel art is nice, I’m not certain that the retro style is the best way to represent EU Digital Policy. If your ne
u/Alfakappa
the pixelated logo is sick, try to pick a font with the same vibe, or at least use it for some of the letters
u/pearstew
no problem at all, good luck! keep me posted :-)
u/justinpenner
This might be a cool idea. Everything pixelated might be confusing but perhaps the first letter in each word, and round the corners of the E to make the pixels obvious (it would also add a sl