Precision Jig Kit for Milling Lumber with Hobbyist Tools

Product/Service Opportunity Analysis:

Identified Need: The Reddit discussion sheds light on a common challenge for DIY woodworkers: the high cost of S4S (surfaced four sides) lumber compared to the expense and space needed for machinery like jointers and planers to process cheaper rough-sawn lumber. New woodworkers, in particular, are looking for ways to access the cost benefits of rough lumber and improve their woodworking quality without a big upfront investment in specialized tools. Multiple comments suggest using jigs with existing tools (like benchtop planers and table saws) as a more affordable and practical solution.

Product Suggestion: A "Hobbyist's Precision Milling Jig Kit" for rough lumber processing.

Kit Components & Features:

  1. Adjustable Planer Sled:

    • Purpose: To flatten one face of a rough or warped board using a standard benchtop thickness planer.
    • Features: A rigid, flat base (e.g., high-quality MDF, phenolic, or aluminum composite) with an integrated, adjustable, and reusable system for securing and shimming the workpiece (e.g., T-tracks with hold-down clamps and adjustable support wedges/blocks, or cam clamps). This provides a more precise and convenient alternative to one-off solutions like hot glue and shims. It should include clear markings for alignment and material capacity.
  2. Table Saw Jointer Sled:

    • Purpose: To create a perfectly straight and square edge on a board using a table saw, mimicking the function of a jointer for edge jointing.
    • Features: A sled designed to run smoothly and accurately in table saw miter slots (or against the fence, depending on the preferred design). It must have a perfectly straight reference edge, robust clamping mechanisms to securely hold various board sizes, and ergonomic handles for safe operation.

Overall Kit Features:

  • Accuracy-focused Design: Constructed from stable, durable materials ensuring long-term precision.
  • Ease of Use: Designed for quick setup and intuitive operation, especially for woodworkers new to milling.
  • Comprehensive Instructions: Includes clear, illustrated manuals and access to online video tutorials demonstrating setup, usage, and safety best practices for each jig.
  • Safety Considerations: Design incorporates safety principles for use with power tools.

Expected Benefit: This jig kit would empower hobbyist woodworkers to confidently and affordably process rough-sawn lumber. It directly addresses their desire to save significant money on both initial machinery purchases (by negating the immediate need for a dedicated jointer and potentially allowing for a more basic planer) and on the ongoing cost of lumber. By providing accurate and easy-to-use tools, the kit enables users to achieve high-quality, precisely dimensioned wood, thereby "upping their game" without the substantial financial outlay and workshop space typically associated with such capabilities.

Origin Reddit Post

r/beginnerwoodworking

As a DIY hobbyist do you buy S4S or rough lumber?

Posted by u/natedoggggggggg06/04/2025
Trying to weigh the options for buying S4S vs rough lumber and getting a planer to square and flatten the sides. I’m pretty much a newbie in hardwood and have done nothing yet with hardwood,

Top Comments

u/Psychological_Tale94
I buy both...depends on what I'm building. For cutting boards I try to get 8/4 hard maple so I dont have to do as much gluing. For the most part I prefer the thicker rough lumber since it giv
u/wythnail2
Here for the love of the game, rough all day, no power tools. Throw on some jams and get sawing and planing, stop when too much sweat is dripping on the work
u/blahblahredditstuff
Buying s4s will definitely get you to the end of a project faster. Squaring a board is time consuming any way you do it. The way it’s described above is how I was taught in the woodshop in s
u/Upper_Brilliant_105
Use a planer sled with hot glue wedges for the first passes and you got a flat board, make a jointer sled for your table saw done easy!
u/MountainViewsInOz
I work exclusively with reclaimed timber, which I scavenge from building sites and skip bins. Doesn't cost me a cent ... but I pay for it heavily in time and wear & tear on my tools (espe
u/Unusual-Following-58
I bought S4S until I was able to afford a planer and a jointer. Now I buy S2S, mill it myself, save some money, and have a wider selection of lumber for my projects.
u/ExtensiveCuriosity
What does the rough cost? $4/bf? $13-$4=$9. Then that dewalt planar is $800; you’d need to run 80+ bf through it to be worthwhile. You gonna run 80+ bf through it? Probably more like 100+;
u/socialist-viking
Get a planer. Best advice I got when I started. Every piece of wood, you'll be looking at it wondering how to make it the right thickness.
u/Upper_Brilliant_105
The choice between rough and s4s is usually ends with tools and time. I actually enjoy milling so
u/AutofluorescentPuku
I prefer rough lumber as I have the means to square it up and surface it.
u/Upper_Brilliant_105
Planer and table saw with a jig is all you need, no need for a jointer and a cheap planer will do everything a hobbyist needs. I build furniture on the side and use rough lumber cause it’s ha
u/aManAndHisUsername
If you have a table saw and a planer, you can get by without a jointer using two very simple jigs.
u/Oceans35
Would a combination of band saw, a hand planer, and a Japanese saw work instead? I mean for an occasional woodworker, may be this will help achieve a higher level of satisfaction, albeit at t
u/natedoggggggggg
Interesting! Maybe I’ll look into a cheaper planer. I’ve seen things about the Hercules and the rigid. But I’m kind of like buy one cry one with the dealt 735x LOL.
u/noashark
For me, I didn’t want to drop $400 plus on a planer so I’m learning how to hand plane instead. I just bought a Stanley No. 5 (type 15) for $30 off FB Marketplace. Significantly cheaper and al
u/Pitiful_Night_4373
Ok well I think there is more to it. The simple question is a matter of money. Let me try and explain. To take rough sawn lumber the process to s4s. You need a jointer 1st and long enough for
u/nrnrnr
I buy S4S. I have a good supplier nearby (Boulter Plywood), and I’ve mostly done small projects. Suppliers of rough lumber are relatively far away and with the quantities I use, I would not
u/Scarcito_El_Gatito
You don’t need to buy a planer and jointer - you can buy a jack plane for 100 bucks, learn how to sharpen and use it. I promise you won’t regret thy in the future. I bought all rough when
u/Snow_Wolfe
If you’re looking to ‘up your game’ in wood working you will need a planer, and probably a jointer.
u/ColonialSand-ers
It’s vastly cheaper to buy rough. I spent $400 combined on my planer and jointer. Saved $700 on the first project. It was a no brainer. Yes you have to consider your time investment but eve
u/Dull-Bat9651
I’ve bought S4S for everything so far, but my lumberyard prices S2S and S3S the same as rough, so I think I’ll try to go S3S whenever possible in the future now that I’ve gotten my hands on a
u/natedoggggggggg
I’ve seen videos showing planers can do what jointers do with some jigs. So I would probably just get the planer, not the jointer. Do you not have a need for a planer? Like if you do cutting
u/Enough-Anteater-3698
How much does the rough cut cost per b/f? How many board feet can you realistically expect to process in a year? Try to get a feel for how long it will take for the planer to pay for itself a

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started