Pricing Guide or Calculator for Handmade Knives and Crafts

A knifemaker, after a long hiatus from crafting and selling knives, is seeking community input on how to price a new handmade knife. The user specifically mentions, "I'd love to hear what others think this is worth," which highlights a common challenge for artisans: valuing their work accurately and confidently, especially when re-entering the market or lacking recent sales data.

Opportunity: There's a clear need for an information resource tailored to help craftspeople, particularly knifemakers, determine fair market pricing for their handmade items.

Product Suggestion:

  1. Comprehensive Handmade Knife Pricing Guide:

    • Format: Ebook, detailed online article series, or a short online course.
    • Content:
      • Material Costing: How to calculate costs for materials like blade steel (e.g., 80CRV2), handle materials (e.g., walnut, maple), pin stock (e.g., stainless steel), and consumables.
      • Labor Valuation: Methods for tracking and valuing hours spent on design, forging, grinding, heat treatment, finishing, sharpening, and sheath making (if applicable). Differentiating rates based on skill.
      • Skill Level & Complexity: Guidance on how to objectively assess and factor in the maker's experience, the intricacy of the design, and the precision of execution.
      • Overhead Costs: Incorporating workshop expenses, tool depreciation, utilities, and marketing costs.
      • Market Research: Strategies for finding and analyzing comparable handmade knives in the market.
      • Pricing Formulas & Strategies: Explaining cost-plus, value-based, and market-based pricing, with examples relevant to handmade knives.
      • Presenting Value: Tips on communicating the value and craftsmanship to potential buyers to justify the price.
  2. Interactive Online Knife Pricing Calculator:

    • Features:
      • User inputs for specific material costs, quantities used, and labor hours for various stages.
      • Scales or inputs for skill level, design complexity, and finish quality.
      • Fields for overhead percentage or fixed overhead costs.
      • Options to select different pricing formulas (e.g., cost x 2, cost x 3, or a more detailed breakdown).
      • Outputs a suggested retail price range.
    • Potential Premium Features: Saving knife profiles, comparing pricing inputs/outputs with anonymized data from other users, generating a printable pricing breakdown sheet, pre-loaded common material costs.

Expected Benefits:

  • Revenue Stream: Sales of the guide (if an ebook or paid course) or revenue from a subscription/one-time purchase model for the calculator (especially for premium features).
  • Empowerment for Artisans: Provides knifemakers with the tools and knowledge to price their work fairly and confidently, leading to better financial sustainability for their craft.
  • Market Efficiency: Helps standardize pricing considerations, making it easier for both new and returning makers to enter the market with appropriate valuations.

Origin Reddit Post

r/knifemaking

First knife in quite a while.

Posted by u/Steel-Turtle05/29/2025
Haven’t made or sold any knives in years, would love some input on what others think this is worth.

Top Comments

u/Proud-Plastic943
This knife is awesome! What material is the handle made of?
u/Proud-Plastic943
This knife is awesome! What material is the handle made of?
u/Steel-Turtle
80CRV2 high carbon steel, walnut and maple handle, stainless steel pins
u/Steel-Turtle
80CRV2 high carbon steel, walnut and maple handle, stainless steel pins

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started