Pricing Guide or Calculator for Handmade Knives and Crafts
A knifemaker, after a long hiatus from crafting and selling knives, is seeking community input on how to price a new handmade knife. The user specifically mentions, "I'd love to hear what others think this is worth," which highlights a common challenge for artisans: valuing their work accurately and confidently, especially when re-entering the market or lacking recent sales data.
Opportunity: There's a clear need for an information resource tailored to help craftspeople, particularly knifemakers, determine fair market pricing for their handmade items.
Product Suggestion:
-
Comprehensive Handmade Knife Pricing Guide:
- Format: Ebook, detailed online article series, or a short online course.
- Content:
- Material Costing: How to calculate costs for materials like blade steel (e.g., 80CRV2), handle materials (e.g., walnut, maple), pin stock (e.g., stainless steel), and consumables.
- Labor Valuation: Methods for tracking and valuing hours spent on design, forging, grinding, heat treatment, finishing, sharpening, and sheath making (if applicable). Differentiating rates based on skill.
- Skill Level & Complexity: Guidance on how to objectively assess and factor in the maker's experience, the intricacy of the design, and the precision of execution.
- Overhead Costs: Incorporating workshop expenses, tool depreciation, utilities, and marketing costs.
- Market Research: Strategies for finding and analyzing comparable handmade knives in the market.
- Pricing Formulas & Strategies: Explaining cost-plus, value-based, and market-based pricing, with examples relevant to handmade knives.
- Presenting Value: Tips on communicating the value and craftsmanship to potential buyers to justify the price.
-
Interactive Online Knife Pricing Calculator:
- Features:
- User inputs for specific material costs, quantities used, and labor hours for various stages.
- Scales or inputs for skill level, design complexity, and finish quality.
- Fields for overhead percentage or fixed overhead costs.
- Options to select different pricing formulas (e.g., cost x 2, cost x 3, or a more detailed breakdown).
- Outputs a suggested retail price range.
- Potential Premium Features: Saving knife profiles, comparing pricing inputs/outputs with anonymized data from other users, generating a printable pricing breakdown sheet, pre-loaded common material costs.
- Features:
Expected Benefits:
- Revenue Stream: Sales of the guide (if an ebook or paid course) or revenue from a subscription/one-time purchase model for the calculator (especially for premium features).
- Empowerment for Artisans: Provides knifemakers with the tools and knowledge to price their work fairly and confidently, leading to better financial sustainability for their craft.
- Market Efficiency: Helps standardize pricing considerations, making it easier for both new and returning makers to enter the market with appropriate valuations.
Origin Reddit Post
r/knifemaking
First knife in quite a while.
Posted by u/Steel-Turtle•05/29/2025
Haven’t made or sold any knives in years, would love some input on what others think this is worth.
Top Comments
u/Proud-Plastic943
This knife is awesome! What material is the handle made of?
u/Proud-Plastic943
This knife is awesome! What material is the handle made of?
u/Steel-Turtle
80CRV2 high carbon steel, walnut and maple handle, stainless steel pins
u/Steel-Turtle
80CRV2 high carbon steel, walnut and maple handle, stainless steel pins