Provide Formatting Feedback to Self-Publishing Poet
Okay, here's the analysis based on the Reddit post provided and the previous context:
Identified Potential Collaborator:
- Name/Identifier: The Original Poster (OP) of the Reddit thread
1kx3z0k
. - Reason: The OP is a self-publishing poet actively looking for specific feedback on book formatting for their second collection. They have a clear need and are open to input.
Collaboration Suggestion:
- Nature of Collaboration: Offer specialized, constructive feedback on their poetry book formatting.
- Approach:
- Engage with the OP's Reddit post directly.
- Acknowledge their challenge with poems of varying lengths.
- Briefly state your expertise (e.g., "As someone with experience in book design/typography for self-published authors, especially poetry...").
- Offer to look at a few sample pages (if they are willing to share them, perhaps via DM or a temporary link) and provide specific, actionable advice on aspects like:
- Consistent placement of titles.
- Use of white space for poems of different lengths.
- Font choices suitable for poetry.
- Handling page breaks or section breaks.
- Overall aesthetic consistency that respects the varied nature of their poems.
- Keep the initial feedback concise and valuable, without overwhelming them.
Expected Benefits (for you, the KOL/Expert):
- Establish a Relationship: Connect directly with a self-publishing author who is actively working on a project and has shown a need for the expertise you possess.
- Showcase Expertise: Providing valuable, specific feedback will clearly demonstrate your skills in book design, typography, and understanding the nuances of poetry formatting. This is a practical demonstration rather than just a claim of skill.
- Potential for Paid Work: If your initial feedback is insightful and helpful, the author might consider hiring you for more comprehensive formatting services for their current book or future collections.
- Goodwill and Word-of-Mouth: Helping an author in a specific area of need can generate significant goodwill. A positive experience might lead to them recommending your services to other authors in their network.
- Content/Case Study Potential: With the author's permission, a successful small interaction could be a point of reference or a mini case study for your portfolio or social proof.
- Low-Risk Engagement: Offering initial feedback is a low-commitment way to initiate a professional relationship and gauge if a larger collaboration would be mutually beneficial.
Origin Reddit Post
r/selfpublish
Want some feedback/opinions on formatting for poetry book!
Posted by u/27_and_51•05/28/2025
hi all!
i am currently in the editing process for my second self published collection of poetry and i've run into a dilemma. would love to hear your feedback as a reader. my poems vary grea
Top Comments
u/pgessert
If you have poems of extremely variable length, it won’t take readers long to figure that out. Whatever pattern you choose, you should make it one that’s really easy to identify. Because if i
u/pgessert
If you have poems of extremely variable length, it won’t take readers long to figure that out. Whatever pattern you choose, you should make it one that’s really easy to identify. Because if i