Specialized Workholding Fixture for CNC Lathe Facing and Centering

Published on 06/15/2025Product Idea Validation (Non-SaaS)

Okay, I've looked into the user's request based on the provided Reddit post information.

Product Opportunity Analysis:

  1. User Need Identification:

    • Problem: The user is looking for a way to securely hold a workpiece for facing and center drilling operations on a CNC machine. Specifically, the workpiece holding mechanism (like a chuck) needs to stay stationary while the tool (drill or facing tool) operates.
    • Context: The assignment is for a CNC lathe, but the operation described (stationary workpiece, live tool) is more like what you'd see on a horizontal mill or a dedicated facing/centering machine. The user mentions it could be a "device for the CNC or a separate machine."
    • Constraint: Standard solutions like a 4-jaw chuck, which usually rotate the workpiece on a lathe, won't work because the chuck needs to be fixed when the drill operates.
    • Implied Need: A specialized fixture or accessory that can be mounted on a CNC machine (likely a lathe, given the context, but adaptable) to perform this task without the workpiece rotating.
  2. Market Gap:

    • The user notes that "old machines that did this" (dedicated facing and centering machines) exist, but information is scarce, suggesting they are not readily available, modern, or easily integrated.
    • Standard lathe operations involve a rotating workpiece, while standard milling operations have a stationary workpiece. The user is trying to solve this within a "CNC lathe" design context or as an accessory.
    • This points to a niche requirement for machine shops that need to perform facing and centering efficiently but may not want or have a dedicated, potentially outdated or expensive, machine for it.
  3. Product Suggestion:

    • Product Name: "Precision Stationary Workpiece Fixture for Facing & Centering" or "Self-Centering Facing and Drilling Fixture for Lathes/Mills."
    • Product Type: B2B Hardware (Machine Tool Accessory).
    • Description: A robust, precision-engineered fixture designed to be mounted on the bed or cross-slide of a CNC lathe (or potentially a CNC mill table).
      • It would feature a self-centering clamping mechanism (e.g., a 3-jaw or 4-jaw scroll chuck design, but one that is locked and does not rotate with the machine spindle) or an adjustable V-block system to securely hold cylindrical or prismatic workpieces.
      • The fixture ensures the workpiece remains perfectly stationary and aligned with the machine's Z-axis (for a lathe, where the tool would be in the main spindle) or X/Y plane for a tool approaching from the spindle (for a mill-like operation on a lathe).
      • It would allow a rotating tool (held in the lathe's main spindle or a live tool turret, or a mill's spindle) to perform facing operations on the end of the workpiece and drill a center hole.
      • Material: Hardened steel for durability and precision.
      • Mounting: T-slot nuts, dedicated mounting plates for common lathe beds/cross-slides.
  4. Key Features & Value Proposition:

    • Stationary Clamping: Solves the core problem of the workpiece needing to be fixed.
    • Self-Centering (or highly adjustable): Reduces setup time and ensures accuracy.
    • Versatility: Allows lathes to perform operations typically requiring a mill or specialized machine.
    • Cost-Effective: Cheaper than a dedicated facing and centering machine.
    • Space-Saving: Uses existing CNC machine capabilities.
    • Improved Workflow: Streamlines the process for preparing stock for further machining operations.
  5. Target Market:

    • Small to medium-sized machine shops.
    • Prototyping labs.
    • Educational institutions with CNC machining programs.
    • Job shops that require flexibility and perform diverse operations.
  6. Expected Benefits (Revenue Potential - Highly Speculative):

    • This is a niche, specialized tooling item.
    • Unit Price: Depending on size, precision, and features, could range from $500 - $2500.
    • Market Size: Difficult to estimate without further research, but let's assume a modest target of capturing a small fraction of machine shops. If there are tens of thousands of machine shops in a target region (e.g., USA), even capturing 0.1% to 0.5% could be significant.
    • Potential Revenue:
      • If 100 units are sold at an average of $1000/unit = $100,000 revenue.
      • If 500 units are sold at an average of $1000/unit = $500,000 revenue.
    • Profit Margin: Specialized tooling can have good margins (e.g., 30-50%) after R&D and manufacturing setup, assuming efficient production.
    • Additional Revenue: Potential for different sizes, custom mounting adapters, or replacement parts.

This product addresses a clearly stated, unsolved technical challenge with a tangible hardware solution for a professional B2B market. It enhances the capability of existing expensive machinery.

Origin Reddit Post

r/machinists

I have a problem in the design for clamping the workpiece for this machine

Posted by u/Successful-Hand894706/15/2025
https://preview.redd.it/glzjmqcxzz6f1.jpg?width=1024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7d7dafc9b3919526f879d37cb5777cfabc7571e7 The problem I'm running into is how to hold the workpiece. I

Top Comments

u/Trivi_13
They used to make facing and centering machines, dedicated equipment.  I  bet they still make them.  That being said, a 4-jaw chuck is adjustable. 
u/dblmca
You are describing a horizontal mill. Where the work piece is stationary and the tool is live. The assignment calls for a CNC lathe. I think you need to go back to first principals and re
u/Successful-Hand8947
it's asking for either a device for the CNC or a separate machine to do the work
u/Successful-Hand8947
Yeah, they told me now that there are some old machines that did this, but since they're so old, I can barely find any information. The chuck issue is that it needs to be fixed when the drill
u/Effective_Motor_4398
You know what they say. Figure it out.

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started