Support scammed author & partner with community for ethical publishing advocacy.

Published on 06/03/2025KOL Promotion Opportunities

Okay, I've taken a look at the Reddit post and its comments.

Analysis of Reddit Post 1l26mey ("I think I got scammed."):

The original poster (OP) shared their experience of likely being scammed by a self-publishing company ("Milton and Hugo") after providing details to a website linking authors with such companies. The OP paid a significant sum and feels foolish and naive. The comments are overwhelmingly supportive of the OP, critical of predatory "vanity presses," and offer advice. Many commenters distinguish between paying for legitimate author services (editing, cover design, formatting) and paying a "publisher" to publish, which is generally seen as a scam.

Identified Potential Influencers / Active Community Members for Collaboration:

  1. The Original Poster (OP) of 1l26mey:

    • Reasoning: They are at the center of a highly engaged discussion about a negative experience with a self-publishing service. They are now acutely aware of the pitfalls and would likely be receptive to ethical alternatives. Their story is a cautionary tale, and a positive resolution or future experience with a legitimate service could become a powerful testimonial.
    • Willingness: High. They've expressed regret and a desire to learn. They are vulnerable and likely seeking genuine help.
  2. Commenter: "I'm so sorry that this happened to you. These companies prey on new writers. As an author, the publishing house should pay you for the right to the book, not the other way around."

    • Reasoning: This commenter self-identifies as an author, shows empathy, and provides a core piece of industry wisdom. Their clear stance against predatory practices and their identity as an author give them credibility.
    • Willingness: Potentially high to advocate for ethical practices and support fellow authors.
  3. Commenter: "Unfortunately, this does happen a lot and it is a scam. You can pay for services like editing, formatting, cover design, etc., and there are legitimate providers of those services. However, paying..." (and similar commenters distinguishing legitimate services from scams)

    • Reasoning: These commenters demonstrate an understanding of the nuances of the self-publishing service industry. They are not wholesale condemning all paid services but are clearly against deceptive "publishing package" scams. They act as knowledgeable voices within the community.
    • Willingness: Likely willing to share their knowledge and endorse ethical service providers if approached correctly.

Collaboration Suggestions and Expected Benefits (Assuming Your Company Offers Ethical Author Services):

  1. With the Original Poster (OP) of 1l26mey:

    • Collaboration Suggestion:
      • Reach out privately with genuine sympathy for their situation.
      • Offer a complimentary consultation to discuss their manuscript and publishing goals, providing genuine advice without immediate sales pressure.
      • Consider offering a significant discount on a specific, transparent service they might need (e.g., professional editing, cover design, or formatting if they decide to self-publish correctly) as a gesture of goodwill to help them recover from their negative experience.
      • Offer to guide them on how to potentially report the scammy company or recoup funds, if applicable.
    • Expected Benefits:
      • Build Immense Goodwill: Demonstrates your company's ethical stance and commitment to author success.
      • Powerful Testimonial: If you successfully help them, their story of being scammed and then finding a legitimate, helpful partner (your company) would be incredibly impactful and authentic.
      • Brand Advocacy: A grateful OP can become a strong advocate for your services within writing communities.
      • Positive PR: Showcasing a "rescue" story can enhance your brand's reputation as a trusted entity in a field with many predators.
  2. With the Commenter ("As an author, the publishing house should pay you..."):

    • Collaboration Suggestion:
      • Acknowledge their insightful comment and alignment with your company's values.
      • Propose a collaboration on content creation. This could be a joint blog post, an interview for your company's blog/podcast, a Q&A session on social media, or co-authoring a guide on "Red Flags in Self-Publishing" or "How to Choose Ethical Author Services."
      • If they have their own platform (blog, social media following), explore cross-promotion.
    • Expected Benefits:
      • Credibility by Association: Aligning with an author who champions ethical practices boosts your company's credibility.
      • Valuable Content: Creates authentic, helpful content that resonates with your target audience (authors wary of scams).
      • Expanded Reach: Leverage their potential network to introduce your brand to more authors.
      • Thought Leadership: Positions your brand as a knowledgeable and ethical leader in the author services space.
  3. With Knowledgeable Commenters (who distinguish legitimate services from scams):

    • Collaboration Suggestion:
      • Engage with their comments in the thread (if appropriate and timely), affirming their points and subtly introducing your company as an example of an ethical provider.
      • Invite them to contribute a guest post to your blog on a topic they are passionate about (e.g., "The Difference Between Vanity Press and Author Services," "Essential Services Worth Paying For as a Self-Publisher").
      • Offer them early access to or a discount on your services in exchange for honest feedback or a review (if they are also authors).
    • Expected Benefits:
      • Community Engagement: Builds rapport within relevant online communities.
      • Diverse Content: Enriches your content offering with varied perspectives.
      • Authentic Reviews/Feedback: Gathers genuine input that can be used for testimonials or service improvement.
      • Grassroots Marketing: Positive word-of-mouth from respected community members.

Overall Strategy: The key is to approach these individuals with genuine empathy and a focus on providing value first, rather than a hard sell. The community around this post is highly sensitized to predatory behavior, so transparency and authenticity are paramount. Highlighting your ethical practices and author-centric approach will be crucial for any successful collaboration.

Origin Reddit Post

r/selfpublish

I think I got scammed.

Posted by u/Emergency_Deer774606/03/2025
It was last year when I provided my name and email to an online website that linked first-time authors with self-publishing companies. A company named Milton and Hugo wrote back to me and tal

Top Comments

u/Tabby_Mc
Why on earth did you send them 1000 after your first instincts were clearly warning you they were dodgy?
u/uwritem
Yeah paying someone to upload (a few clicks and boxes) is a scam.
u/ShotcallerBilly
It blows my mind the amount of people who spend enough time on the internet to find these obscure publishers, join mailing lists, etc, but can’t find 30 seconds for one google search that wou
u/Dramatic-Concern-655
See I'll be honest these are generally pubishing companies run by single person who is doing nothing but extracting money from you and then he/she/they will use AI to make cover and publish o
u/Long_Roll_7046
Never, ever write a check for anything unless you are purchasing a service that you seek out. Even then, do due diligence on any company you contemplate doing business with. Treat everyone
u/Orion004
Vanity publishing is a scam. When you pay someone to publish your book, it's a scam. Even the ones masquerading as "publishing services" are scams. Such companies often lack the skills to co
u/Maggi1417
This has nothing to do with being a new writer, that's just common sense. Don't give someone a large sum of money without making absolutely sure they're legitimate, especially not if you alre
u/Throwawaydecember
If someone is asking for money, you are getting scammed.
u/Maggi1417
>I am an International Uni student and money is very tight on my end,  And yet, you forked over a thousand dollars just so you could "get a feel for what they were providing". I hope you
u/Long_Roll_7046
Never, ever write a check for anything unless you are purchasing a service that you seek out. Even then, do due diligence on any company you contemplate doing business with. Treat everyone
u/Throwawaydecember
If someone is asking for money, you are getting scammed.
u/p-d-ball
You're getting wildly scammed. 1. They used AI b/c they either can't do the work or are too lazy to. 2. they asked you for money (and you paid it! bad you!) and then are hounding you for more
u/brondyr
Charging to upload the file is a major red flag. Unless they charge 5 bucks for it
u/brondyr
If you paid for publishing, you got scammed
u/istara
OP almost certainly did, but paying for publishing services is not necessarily a scam. There are businesses that package up a range of services - formatting, cover design, file upload - it's
u/p-d-ball
You're getting wildly scammed. 1. They used AI b/c they either can't do the work or are too lazy to. 2. they asked you for money (and you paid it! bad you!) and then are hounding you for more
u/ChrSaran
As a self-published author, you pay for your editor(s), you pay for your cover artist, but you never pay to get published. If they ask you for money to get you published, they are a scam. The
u/istara
The scam in this is that they positioned themselves as a "publishing company". This just isn't how publishing works - this was 100% a vanity press. If you want to pay someone to save you the
u/creatingcuriously
What's your team? Is there a website I can see your services on?
u/Lemon_Typewriter
Anyone seeking out authors online is highly suspect. Indie authors usually publish themselves and large publishing houses use query processes and have real human editors and marketers. Sadly
u/creatingcuriously
You seem so kind and nice to new writers trying to learn a complicated journey.
u/[deleted]
[deleted]
u/Orion004
Vanity publishing is a scam. When you pay someone to publish your book, it's a scam. Even the ones masquerading as "publishing services" are scams. Such companies often lack the skills to co
u/Spoiledanchovies
I'm so sorry that this happened to you. These companies prey on new writers. As an author, the publishing house should pay you for the right to the book, not the other way around.
u/Flee4All
There is no such thing as a "self-publishing company" unless it's one that you own strictly for publishing your own work.
u/Lemon_Typewriter
Anyone seeking out authors online is highly suspect. Indie authors usually publish themselves and large publishing houses use query processes and have real human editors and marketers. Sadly
u/istara
Agreed, but there are still writers who cannot manage it. Also these companies are often uploading it onto their accounts which is also highly problematic. They go bust - how do you get owner
u/Curious_Stuff_7010
Unfortunately this does happen a lot and it is a scam. You can pay for services like editing, formatting, cover design etc and there are legitimate providers of those services. However, payin
u/Maggi1417
>I am an International Uni student and money is very tight on my end,  And yet, you forked over a thousand dollars just so you could "get a feel for what they were providing". I hope you
u/Emergency_Deer7746
I am very thankful for all the comments provided here. I was very naive and foolish, especially as a first time author. I went in blindly and got done dirty. Though the situation is unsalvage
u/FullNefariousness931
So you noticed AI was used and then ignored it and paid $1000? Congrats, you got scammed and you seemed to be okay with it.
u/HorrorAuthor_87
I'm so sorry that happened to you, but, yes, unfortunately you were scammed. Try to learn from it, and don't give up. Keep writing.
u/Duffalpha
Unless you're in academia, in which case its mandatory, apparently...
u/brondyr
If you paid for publishing, you got scammed
u/Duffalpha
Unless you're in academia, in which case its mandatory, apparently...
u/Anzai
Yeah it’s a scam. You don’t ever pay for publishing unless it’s a vanity press or a scam. And a vanity press is just another name for a scam if they’re offering it with any implication that y
u/FullNefariousness931
So you noticed AI was used and then ignored it and paid $1000? Congrats, you got scammed and you seemed to be okay with it.
u/Orion004
Even the ones masquerading as "publishing services" are scams. Such companies often lack the skills to complete all parts of the job to a professional level, like professional editing, cover
u/BenReillyDB
😑 How are yall this naïve?
u/ThisThroat951
I guess my first issue was: why are you looking for a publisher now? In your first statement you said it was an unfinished manuscript. As a student that’s not in a great financial position yo
u/HorrorAuthor_87
I'm so sorry that happened to you, but, yes, unfortunately you were scammed. Try to learn from it, and don't give up. Keep writing.
u/istara
The scam in this is that they positioned themselves as a "publishing company". This just isn't how publishing works - this was 100% a vanity press. If you want to pay someone to save you the
u/Emergency_Deer7746
I am very thankful for all the comments provided here. I was very naive and foolish, especially as a first time author. I went in blindly and got done dirty. Though the situation is unsalvage
u/Serious_Mirror_6927
Scammed sorry
u/Spoiledanchovies
I'm so sorry that this happened to you. These companies prey on new writers. As an author, the publishing house should pay you for the right to the book, not the other way around.
u/AccordingBag1772
People got more money to waste than most people eat on.
u/Curious_Stuff_7010
Unfortunately this does happen a lot and it is a scam. You can pay for services like editing, formatting, cover design etc and there are legitimate providers of those services. However, payin
u/Emergency_Deer7746
That was from my savings in high-school, I was preparing them in the hopes that I do get into publishing. So yeah, I wasted it, now i gotta save more.
u/Vegtam1297
You're getting downvoted, but it's true. There are actual legitimate hybrid publishers and such, but they are few and far between. The best thing is to just go by the advice "never pay for pu

Ask AI About This

Get deeper insights about this topic from our AI assistant

Start Chat

Create Your Own

Generate custom insights for your specific needs

Get Started